All Comments about...

Up 2009

The best movie of Pixar, in my opinion.

loading replies

I cried :'( amazing film though

loading replies

Don't wait to tell your Ellie you love her

loading replies

So good. I cry every single time.

loading replies

Imaginative, fun and moving - as close to perfect as Pixar has ever been.

loading replies

I love this movie. It's probably the best movie ever made after The Lion King. The story is beautiful, the first 10 minutes alone, telling the story of Carl and Ellie, have me crying. In 10 minutes it is told the most beautiful love story I've ever seen and it portrays so beautifully everything one looks for, to find and spend the rest of one's life with someone. To have a great adventure next to someone, with no regrets even if dreams were unfulfilled. And how having a heart broken, someone so important taken away, and to find others that again complete us. Such a beautiful message.

loading replies

Depressing intro, movie was okay but didn't like the music!!

loading replies

MajorMercyFlush. Who's complaining about the Parental Guidance rating? The Incredibles was rated PG for Violence. Shrek was rated PG for suggestive Language. No one is suggesting the show should have been PG13. I was just making a tongue in cheek comment about a movie that I despised.

People really go off the deep end when you insult a Pixar movie apparently. LOL.

loading replies

hands down the best goddam movie in all of Disney's history!!

loading replies

The begin is a beautiful but very depressing story. Overall I found the movie just plain sad throughout. It only gets happy about the last ten minutes. Not exactly what I look for in a family film. Definitely would be a good one if you’re looking for a movie to sob through. Chalk this one to “not my type of film”.

loading replies

that was a good movie. they was old

this movie had Everything.
1. old ppl
2. fat little baby birds
3. a doggy

loading replies

This movie is so sad and so beautiful.

loading replies

@stryjewski (missed your post back at the time, and was doing some housekeeping) -

You are right no one, including me, suggested it be PG-13 simply that if you are trying to explain dead babies, heaven and attempted murder to a crying child its probably at the upper end of PG for them. Your comments didn't come across as tongue in cheek at all as evidenced by dunpealhunter's query too. It was your post that piqued my interest as you seemed to have gone off the deep end. :)

The rest (14 of the 18 lines) of it was "side note" commentary about ratings in general and a great documentary discussing them. As Killerc pointed out these forums aren't for 5 y/o (tut tut FatalMuzza) so figured your/dunpealhunter post served as a good jumping off point to another semi related topic that may draw interest.

Reading "Great film/episode" "I liked it" "I hate it" comments over and over gets a little stale.

Anyway...

loading replies

Beautiful movie. The story starts of just cute but is actually very strong and really beautiful. The music is on point, makes it even more magical and Russel is adorable!

loading replies

I feel completely alone in this, but Up was NOT my favorite Pixar movie (not even close!) The commercials showed funny bits with a kid and a dog, but the actual movie hits you in the face with a depressing intro and a not-very-uplifting storyline. I always assume that Pixar movies will have some sappiness, but this one made me downright sad in an unexpected way. No thanks! I much prefer The Incredibles and Finding Nemo.

loading replies

excellent film, a family favourite

loading replies

I felt a bit upset because it made me cry in the cinema. But it's a good Pixar movie.

loading replies

The best movie of animation that I have seen in a lot of time! So good for children as for adults. 10/10

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Very good

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Love love love it!

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

I love this movie it's one of my favorite Disney movies

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Great movie!

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Mu family's favorite

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Wow! One of the best

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Loved this film could watch it over and over

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Loved it!

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Awesome

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

A really great movie for the whole family to watch together.

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Our 3-4 year old son loved this movie.

loading replies

PG Film, PG thread ;)

loading replies

This is slightly above average for me, not one of the best.

loading replies

I had heard great things about this movie but never took the time to watch it. But, wow! What a beautiful movie!

loading replies

An all-time favourite. Definitely one of Pixar's greatest movies, it's got humour, emotion and even a bit of action! Highly recommend it if you're looking for a good cry and a good laugh! :smile: 10/10

loading replies

One hundred years from now, film scholars will study the 15 wordless minutes near the beginning of this movie as one of the finest examples of storytelling across any medium or genre. I say this without threat of hyperbole.

loading replies

the most beautiful love story ! :heart:

loading replies

Yes, the opening sequence is touching, but I prefer the far superior “La Maison en Petits Cubes” which came out the year prior. The rest of the movie is forgettable and struck me as distinctly unfunny and weirdly mean-spirited. The gender issues with the bird, the bizarre talking dogs, the childhood hero turned psycho all turned me off in a big way.

loading replies
8

Shout by Deleted

First 10 minutes are among some of the best scenes in any movie, period. Then the rest happens.

loading replies

the dogs and that dumb high pitched voice really bring this down for me.

loading replies

A fun and charming adventure.

'Up' certainly knows how to tug at the heartstrings. It creates a very meaningful story around Carl Fredricksen (Ed Asner), with the early scenes particularly standing out as superb.

I don't overly enjoy the parts with Dug (Bob Peterson) and Kevin (Pete Docter), not that they are bad, though everything with Fredricksen, Russell (Jordan Nagai) and Charles F. Muntz (Christopher Plummer) is entertaining and/or hearty.

Asner and Nagai do terrific, in what is one of Disney's 'best of the rest' films. There is some lovely music by Michael Giacchino, too. Go watch!

loading replies

Shout by Deleted
BlockedParent2016-09-22T00:50:15Z— updated 2019-04-02T22:04:25Z

this is even better than finding nemo

loading replies
8

Shout by Deleted

Excellent computer animation, mediocre storyline -- albeit good enough. I believe this is as good for children as adults -- but do watch for any children getting anything of the same idea to try on their own. (You know how kids can be.) Not very 'action-packed' but not boring either. It'll keep your attention as you wonder what will happen next.

loading replies

One of the better "new" animated movies (but somehow they just don't reach "Ice Age", "Shrek" or "Monster's Inc.").

loading replies

Shout by Deleted

Starts making you cry but very disappointing end.

loading replies

Shout by Deleted

Aww I watched this with my little brothers and baby sister.
we enjoyed it

loading replies
10

Shout by Ben
VIP
OG
13

What if Michael Bay Directed "UP"?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5KQQWlIgGc

So funny!
:D :D :D

loading replies

Cinema Paco 1. Picture 5/5 Sound 4.5 / 5 .. The first 10 minutes are stunning how good they are. Then it's fine, some scenes very well "

loading replies
8

Shout by Deleted

Dramatic Disney film!

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Definitely a year jerker. One of the best movies since Toy Story and I was fascinated by the plot!

loading replies

An 7 for this movie because you can see how much love and attention it got, it's also an original story but gets you dazzled off at the end.

loading replies
8

Shout by Deleted

Cute movie

loading replies
8

Shout by Deleted

It was a trap! But a good one.

loading replies

Nice movie

loading replies

Shout by Deleted

Why a 5 yr old would be interested in this site and reading the comments is beyond me. Maybe you should be controlling your children on the internet rather than thinking that a site which hosts 18
+ and Unrated descriptions of movies/TV Shows, that the commenters should be doing your job for you.

loading replies

Nice job advertising Shortbus in a Disney thread 5yo's are reading MajorMercyFlush. I'm sure their well into the opening scene by now. Don;t forget to add urls to mentioned movies to make it even simpler. :)

loading replies

dunpealhunter hits the nail on the head.

@stryjewski;
PG - Parents Guidence recommended... It's an advisory. Parent. Guide. Assumptions lead to exactly what you've said. I've had exactly the same situation before. One kid was cool the other lost their mind.

This is absolutely not directed at you, so please don't take it this that way, it's a broad personal observation. Too many people see ratings classification as a greenlight as opposed to a give way. They are meant to inform not insinuate. The ultimate decision to expose either themselves or there guardianship lies with that party and the fine print of whatever they are using to base that decision upon.

Random MajorMercyFlush side note: There is a fantastic documentary called "This Film is Not Yet Rated" that delves into the inner workings of the MPPA and how gratuitous violence is far more acceptable than any notion of sexuality, that a numerous heads can explode bloody over people and can get an M yet the idea of a pube will get an instant R (NC-17) and be limited or rejected to screenings. It is seriously worth watching to see how we you are being informed/swayed. I say "you" and mean those under the MPPA. I live in Australia and have a staunch enough industry that when films are refused classifcation, for example Ken Park, 9 Songs, Shortbus (that one's for you Fatalmuzza) we question their authority at a level that can be heard and demand they justify it, regardless of it's artistic merit. We simply won't stand for being told as adults something is deemed beyond the capacity for us to decide whether it should be seen by us. In the case of Ken Park, it was refused classifaction and one of our highly regarded national figures held their own public screening to draw attention to the fact that ratings are informative yet the ultimate decision lies with a responcible individual. It was shutdown, she was released without charge and is seen as landmark. All of those films were reclassified the moment someone looked their way.

Thanks for playing.

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

I really like all Disney movies.

loading replies

Are you serious? This movie is rated PG, but it is in no way as shocking as you just described. My 6 year old nephew saw it and liked it very much.

I thought it was a great story. A man who since he was a kid had a dream together with his best friend who later became his wife, once he finally decides to follow up on his childhood dream years later its too late for his wife. But he doesn't give up and uses the house in witch he lived with his wife and has so many fond memories of to go to that far away place of witch he always dreamed of going to.

Like always Pixar delivered a masterpiece. The expectations of their movies is always very high, but i think this movie was a success and that they achieved the goals they had in mind.

loading replies

So I'm watching this with my young daughter and the Fing lady in the film miscarries? WHAT? Now my older kid is like, where's the baby? Where? I have to explain to her WTF happened and it turns into an hour long conversation about babies dying and not every baby is born alive, do they go to heaven? Christ.. Thanks Walt Disney, you jerks.... Ok through that.. Then the show gets so boring I fall asleep only to wake up to my younger kid crying because the main characters hero is trying to KILL him.. Why's his hero trying to kill him daddy? Thanks again Walt Disney! My kids refer to this movie as "The one where the baby dies" Good show!

loading replies
Loading...