I agree the fighting scene was silly and Bella's "gifts" were a bit overkill. That being said, I think some of the criticism is a bit harsh when you consider the absolutely terrible movies that have been released in the last few months. This may not be the best movie but it is by no means the absolute worst either. (Though BD1 does go on my worst list. THAT movie was terrible)
Shout by DeletedBlockedParentSpoilers2013-02-16T20:32:52Z
Despite the fighting scene being silly, I enjoyed watching it. Probably my favorite moment from all of the movies. But this is still mediocre at best.