One of the poorest 3D animation movies I've seen yet.

Wonderful animation and rendering. It had it's good moments, but overall, the film was just weird. There were several oddities of the writing, and in some parts the talking was a little too fast to understand. Also, with some characters, it was puzzling as to what species they were even supposed to be. The acting was very good, but the script could have been a bit different.

Best detailed graphics ever, after the tin tin... the story was pretty all. Any way i love johny depp. So i love this film too!

Continually surprised how many people mention the references in this film without mentioning the most obvious, Chinatown.

First things first: the animation looks absolutely fantastic and the character design is awesome. Depp does another great captain Jack impression, which you either like or not. Lots of references to other movies, with the obvious ones being Fear and loathing, Pirates of the Caribbean and spaghetti westerns in general. The movie atmosphere feels very different from other animated movies, so I can only applaud the effort to shake up the genre.
But to be honest, it didn't pull me in. It tried to be too many things at once, and therefore failed at being really good at any of them. There were only a couple funny moments, the 'religious' theme was scattered and sometimes awkward, the Clint Eastwood vibe didn't go well with the funny side, the story was too simple for adults but too slow (and perhaps too dark) for kids.
Still I can recommend watching it, even if it's just for the visuals or the Clint Eastwood vibe. Just don't expect a masterpiece.