Riley is planning a wedding for her friend, Katie (Melissa Tang), and gets everybody involved. Danny and Tucker ruin the wedding cake and they try to fix it. After a night of partying before the wedding, Ben and Katie awaken to find themselves in bed together. Katie feels extremely guilty and tries to call off the wedding before Ben gives her a speech about true love, something that touches Riley. It turns out that Gene (Trent Garrett), a jerk from their high school days, was playing a prank on them and Ben & Katie never actually did anything. After the wedding, Ben asks Riley for a dance, while a jealous Danny looks on.