Negri's Music Shop needs Rogers' help when the lady at the cashier must see her sick child. Negri and Rogers propose a Neighborhood of Make-Believe story in which the King and Queen leave Tuesday for their errands.

Rogers and Mr. McFeely make treats with peanuts and peanut butter. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Tuesday is still angry that his parents are running errands all the time.

Wearing a lei of peanut shells as he enters, Mister Rogers will promote reading the rest of the week. Mr. McFeely brings a video on how people make peanut butter. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Henrietta Pussycat suggests that Cornflake S. Pecially's factory start a caring center for the children of the factory's workers.

Rogers visits oboist Natasha at Negri's Music Shop. The Neighborhood of Make-Believe begins work in earnest on the new child-caring center at Corny's factory.

Balloon Artist Bruce Franco visits Rogers' television house. He has even made a balloon Trolley. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Prince Tuesday helps those who run the child-caring center at Corny's factory.

A major crisis has arisen in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe. Their nearby landfill at Someplace Else has reached the saturation point.

Messrs. Rogers and McFeely visit the neighborhood recycling center. Everything is orderly there, which cannot be said for Make-Believe. Westwood Mayor Maggie informs that their landfill has been filled completely.

Mister Rogers discusses making artwork out of old objects. This precipitates Mr. McFeely's video, showing his visit with a spare-parts artist.

Mister Rogers recalls the snorkeling adventure he shared with Sylvia Earle. It leaves little time for Neighborhood of Make-Believe, which needs help from two of Northwood's goats.

Mr. McFeely brings a goat to the television house to dispel a few myths. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Mrs. Dingleborder and the goats of Northwood complement each other's plans to solve the appalling garbage crisis.

Mister Rogers enters with a bandaged hand. He illustrates (as Lady Aberlin demonstrates to Ana Platypus in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe) that nothing changes underneath a bandage. Rogers attends the Marsalis Family's rehearsals at Negri's Music Shop.

Mr. McFeely brings materials on how adhesive bandages are made. Rogers puts one such bandage on a rag doll. That rag doll becomes the plot point in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, as King Friday XIII and Prince Tuesday believe the doll to life.

Chuck Aber brings a guest to the television house. Joining them are two wolves. Later in the show, Mister Rogers' son Jim and grandson Alex stop over. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Aber is dressed as a wolf, ready to offer a wolf costume to someone else.

Rogers reads a book a teenage girl had made for her father. He then puts stuffing in a toy wolf for a friend. Later in the program, Ella Jenkins visits (as does Chuck Aber) to perform some songs. In between, those in the Neighborhood of Make-Believe discuss their feelings about wolves. Daniel Striped Tiger tells those at school that he doesn't have a musical father, like Ana and Prince Tuesday.

Rogers discusses music with Yo-Yo Ma and, when son Nicholas Ma arrives, Rogers helps perform a trio of The Skaters' Waltz. In the Neighborhood of Make-Believe, Lady Aberlin finds a musical father for Daniel.