Slay Everyone, Trust No One
20 contestants from previous seasons of Survivor return for another shot at the million dollars. The contestants arrive on a beach via a helicopter and are divided into two tribes, heroes and villains. After the tribes meet, they participate in their first reward challenge. The heroes win the reward of fire but during the challenge, Stephenie and Rupert both suffer injuries but are able to stay in the game.
The villains arrive at their campsite. Right away, Russell approaches Danielle to form an alliance to the final two and then says the same thing to Parvati. At the heroes' beach, the tribe starts to build their shelter and even catch four chickens from the wild.
The next morning, the villains joke how Jerri and Coach could become romantically involved after a little flirting during the night. Over on the heroes, all the tribemates who were both on the same season before try to align with each other again. Back on the villains beach, Rob is successful in creating fire.
That night, the heroes are not able to get a full night's sleep after Sugar starts annoying Colby. But the next day, they enjoy a meal of chicken soup. Both tribes get tree mail and participate in their first Immunity Challenge. After the villains win, the heroes return to camp and everyone seems to have their own opinion on who should be voted out. Sugar suggests Amanda but Colby wants Sugar out. However, Tom thinks Cirie should go, and Cirie thinks it should be Stephenie.