All Comments about...

Stargate SG-1: Season 5

5x19 Menace

This is actually a pretty significant episode as it provides the origin story of the replicators.

loading replies

We found something that survived an extinction-level replicator attack. Should we call the Asgard now? Or wait until we have an actual replicator in the base and a pissed off android who can make more of them?

loading replies

Carter yet again shows she really isn't that smart. It really isn't that hard to see that Reese is upset. Does it matter if she is organic or not? They have all dealt with artificial versions of themselves and know they act identical to the organic originals. Yet Carter makes it seem like she want to dissect Reese without any regard to Reese herself.

Amazingly, Daniel is spot on with his analysis. I can't believe he had to explain the situation to Carter for several minutes. It should have been a 10 second conversation for Carter to realize she fucked up telling Reese she was different...

loading replies
7

Shout by wpafbo79
VIP
4
BlockedParent2021-06-17T08:10:38Z— updated 2021-08-01T06:42:28Z

O'Neill royally fucked up and he is too arrogant to admit it. What an asshat. He didn't even bother to assess the situation after a comms blackout. Catastrophic fail. O'Neill is getting worse and worse with every episode. He is definitely a liability now. It used to be just Daniel and Carter, but now O'Neill screws things up regularly, too.

loading replies

Ugh Cecile from the Flash…

loading replies

The story concept here isn't great, but the episode works thanks to a strong performance from guest star Danielle Nicolet. She plays Reese with a fantastic childish impatience and temperament that does make you sympathise with her. She and Michael Shanks also played off each other well. I never found the Replicators to be a very interesting enemy, but this at least has some surprise value in finding out their origin.

Good ending moment for Daniel and Jack, too.

loading replies

I think Daniel is a closet robosexual.

loading replies
Loading...