Warning - Spoilers included for both this and the original British version.
Everything that made the original British version of Utopia special, intriguing and ultimately great is lost in this new version from writer, Gillian Flynn. The main thing that made the original show stand out so greatly was not just the story it created but through the visuals and the score, it was a stylised masterpiece. It was something we hadn’t seen before. This is not that. In Gillian Flynn’s own words, she wanted to make it “more gritty” and wanted to “Americanize” Utopia for the US audience and she’s certainly succeeded in that, but at the same time, she has, as mentioned taken away all of its wonder.
The introduction of new character Samantha adds absolutely nothing at all and when she is killed abruptly there is no sadness from either the audience or really from the rest of the cast. She dies and the reaction is not one of mourning but just a bit of shock. Honestly though, as mentioned she was a nothing character anyway. The show was trying to build her up as “the leader” but it just felt like they were stretching Becky’s original character across two characters instead and not leaving enough to make Becky interesting afterwards. Instead, both are barely a shade as interesting as the original character and ‘Deals Syndrome’ here is just a side-note. It may as well have not been mentioned.
But they don’t get much better from there. Rod (Lee in the original) is killed off early but again had no personality really as the show instead tries incredibly hard not to pull focus away from how excessively weird Arby is this time around. Arby in the original show is conflicted and simple-minded, easy to please and later builds his own life, grows, tries to have a family and saves them. Arby never gets that respect this time, instead being turned into a stereotypical Autistic man who has the voice of a serial killer and you’re never allowed to feel for him. He’s given no backstory.
Jessica, obviously the main character in the original is given a little more time than others here but Sasha Lane’s depiction of her is much like Arby’s. In the original, yes she is brutally honest, forward and knows she has to get things done right to save herself and the others but she also has an almost child-like innocence about her – A sense of wonder if you will. She is seeing things for the first time. She is experiencing love for the first time, she smiles, finds things funny and develops a relationship with Grant that’s almost like a big sister. Here, she is just brutal. Nothing else is given to her as a characteristic and it’s just weird when she splits from the rest of the group and they have an embrace in the final episode. None of them ever got that close to one another so what are they embracing for? They don’t like one another.
For some reason they’ve made Jessica’s story that she wants to find her daddy and go home rather than seek revenge and save people too. She’s selfish, yet cries her eyes out when she finds out daddy might be dead and that’s just so out-of-character it’s as weird as Arby.
Grant isn’t given enough time either but Alice is given far more. Wilson, I have fewer complaints about and Desmin Borges was a solid choice in his role, as was Rainn Wilson as Michael.
The main issue though outside of not caring about any characters, the wonderful score being a series of dulcet tones this time around and the visuals being unspectacular is that in this version of the show, the audience have no choice on what to believe. It isn’t until 42 minutes before the end that we’re told what the real reason behind the entire conspiracy is. We are given just 42 minutes of the near-eight hours to think about Dr. Christie’s world-saving sterilisation vaccine. In the original show we find this out around half-way through and it allows the audience to feel conflicted because we are given genuine reasons for it and enough information to allow us to truly think – what if?
There is so much that is lost in this version of Utopia that it ultimately isn’t worth the time. Instead, Amazon should have just pushed the original show like Netflix has with The Fall. The original show was so unique and ahead of it’s time that trying to re-make that was going to be a struggle and it does unfortunately fail here – As expected. Watching this version, we just feel like Dr. Christie is leading a cult who are trying to change the world with their “purpose” and it almost feels like this is because it is American. By that I mean, the original is more of a government conspiracy and I don’t think a show about a viral pandemic being led by the government would go down very well right now so it’s turned into a cult instead and it just feels silly.
And don’t get me started on John Cusack’s catchphrase, “What have you done today to earn your place in this crowded world?” – It is said SO MANY times that you just don’t care. I think Flynn thought this sounded edgey and cool or something but it just sounds awkward, clunky and becomes a catchphrase for the cult. I never want to hear that phrase again.
Ultimately, it’s predictable… We knew Colleen was on the bad guy’s side. We knew Dr. Christie was Mr. Rabbit. Milner was pointless in this version too. At the end of the series, you’re just left not really caring for anyone. Nobody is likeable except Michael and then he drives off into the sunset with an egg for some reason!
This is thankfully, just entirely forgetful and you can go back to the original and forget Gillian Flynn’s Utopia ever happened. She just doesn’t “get it” despite believing she did.
I have only watched the first episode yet (still plan to finish the rest because I don't have anything better to do anyway haha) but you're better off just watching the british original. This is just a dumb-downed americanised bad cosplay fan-fiction.
I feel like if the original didn't exist this would be solid binge watch for a weekend. Nothing more but a decent show. But the original does exist. And it's IMO a fucking masterpiece. So just watch that.
EDIT: After E2 - what the fuck have they done with Jessica? It's so fucking stupid. They are obviously trying to be different to the original to stand out. But it just doesn't work. Fuck that. Arby and Lee are just hollowed out shadows of themselves. Nothing stands out as being good. I'm giving up on this. WATCH THE ORIGINAL!!!
I was not aware this was originally a British series I just found out thru one of the other comments here. I'll have to go find that and watch it.
In the meantime, I did enjoy this first season. Even though it hits very close to living in 2020.
I may have to come back here and adjust my comments once I've seen the original version. In the meantime, I do believe this is a fairly solid show and worth a watch.
UPDATE: I found and watched the British version. It's definitely more interesting, more stylized and maybe a little less tidy than the American version. If you have a choice between watching the British or the American version I highly recommend the British.
Do a favor for yourself and watch the REAL "Utopia (2013 UK)", one of the best shows ever! This "MTV-friendly-version" remake it's hard to watch... a shame... GO FOR THE REAL UTOPIA!
Why would you want to remake something that's already perfect? Why would you want to remake it that badly?
Definitely not as good as the British series.
Please IGNORE all the pretentious reviewers say “like omg, the original was so wonderful and this just sucks”. It’s the most common annoying trope for no life’s to say how bad a remake is compared to the the original. They feel a sense of loyalty which I get but unless it’s my favorite show of all time I always Judge something on its own merrits. The same people reviewed the US version of The Office the same way, which as any sane person knows is insane. They are very different animals and good for very different reasons.
I loved this adaption of Utopia and is one of the best shows in 2020. Cusak makes a great
Villain, Dwight from The Office was awesome, and the story is surprisingly relatable to the current Covid situation. It is perfectly paced, me and my wife could not get enough.
I was shocked after watching the first 2 episodes that it was based on the British miniseries... BECAUSE THEY'RE NOTHING ALIKE OR SIMILAR AT ALL!
While I enjoyed the US version, but mostly found it "Meh" and all over the place it does not compare to the genius of the UK version.
I EMPLORE YOU TO WATCH THE UK VERSION!
This doesn’t measure up to the UK 2013-2014 series, by the same name, but it’s not bad, either, and eerily appropriate for pandemic binging. The UK had 2 seasons, so, Amazon will probably do so, as well. If you have the choice watch the original series, I gave it a 9 (uniquely clever) out of 10. I give this series a 6 (fair) to 7 (good). [Action Drama]
For those who are a little apprehensive, I've got to admit it's not the worst.
By the third episode it's diverged enough from the Original, that you can spend less time comparing, and more time enjoying it.
Not great, not bad. Definitely watchable and worth it at least once. Obviously if you've never seen the original, find a way to watch it because it is amazing.
I loved the original British series and the first two or three episodes of this were similarly gripping ( if you don't mind shows that are incredibly dark and spectacularly badly timed vis à vis world events). Unfortunately, as is often the case with a high-concept series it looks like they didn't have any idea how to finish it. In fact, the ending is so terrible I can't help thinking either it had to be produced in a great rush or it was a perverse attempt to ensure no second series would be done to finish it properly (although apparently there is a second series I can't access?)
The science of this show is wrong in so many levels lol good acting though
The UK Channel 4 series this is loosely based on (https://trakt.tv/shows/utopia) was excellent - reviews of this one are more mixed but I'll certainly be giving it a try!
I just finished this US version and it's not up comparable to the original, it may not be "terrible"v itself, but if you watched the original this is just a faded worst shadow of it; if you didn't, skip this and GO ON THE ORIGINAL UK VERSION NOW!
HOSTAGES S02 (2020) REVIEW
.
.
Plot :
A group of young adults, who meet online, get a hold of a cult underground graphic novel, which not only pins them as a target of a shadowy deep state organization, but also burdens them with the dangerous task of saving the world.
Review :
Utopia is not just another America saves the world show, but don't we still watch Marvel movies which has the same repetative theme , YES we do. Utopia is based on a cult graphic comic of which the real life manifestation is parallelly happening simultaneously. A group of friends after able to figure out the hidden meaning in the comics are subjected to killers of a deep state organization and how they unravel the mystery of the comics is all the show about. The show has everything you can ask for Action , Drama, Comedy, Sci Fi, Thrills and is filled with unravelling of mysteries and truths. The Show has a great production value backed by great performances by everyone involved. A band of people trying to save the world seems too mainstream but along with this it has propaganda stories, talks about conspiracies and much more. S01 is just 8 Episodes and I binged it all without breaks.
Talking about performances my favourite is Arby, he is soft spoken , humble but at the same time a ruthless killer and the character arc shifts drastically towards the end. The band Wilson is a genius but easily manipulative, Becky is the emotional one, Ian is the dedicated , Grant is the smartest kid and Alice is the cutest one. John Cusack is outstanding as Kevin Christie.
The fact that Utopia is a remake of British Series of the same name it has been compared to it and thus the less IMDb ratings but I assure that if you haven't seen The British version you gonna love the American Utopia. With all Episodes meticulously filled with twists and fun elements, Utopia for me is one of the best shows I have seen this year.
:white_check_mark: Verdict : Overall, Utopia is a bingeworthy pandemic drama you should be watching for its interesting premise, bold and strong performances, edge of the seat screenplay and the regular doses of mysteries. Recommended to watch (Watch it Now :thumbsup:)
.
.
.
- Follow in Instagram for More : @RiteshReviews
Shout by whos_ur_buddhaBlockedParent2020-10-06T01:17:06Z
I tried it. I can’t get past episode 3 because it’s just terrible. Maybe if I never watched the original version, this might be slightly bearable. Anyway skip this show. It’s bad. Go see the original version.