Just to preface this, I thought A Force Awakens was emotionless trash that undermined the entire purpose of the original three films.

Rogue One was the opposite.

The best thing about this movie was the emotional impact. It underlined the sacrifices made to make the original trilogy possible. Some people have called it long, but that helped build up characters that you actually felt for, and who weren't carbon copy ripoffs (cough cough A Force Awakens). The final scenes as the two main characters face their fate, recognizing that it was worth it, gave such a high emotional payoff. Each major death scene actually made you feel something.

The second best thing was K-2SO. Very funny, and much needed comedic (but not goofy) relief.

The CGI for landscapes and the world creation was outstanding. When I see a movie like Star Wars I want to be amazed and see things that I haven't seen done before. I want to be impressed and drawn into new, beautifully crafted worlds. In this respect, the movie just kept delivering over and over.

The cinematography was great during the action sequences. The sequences looked epic, and the violence and sacrifice felt meaningful. The Vader fight sequence was intense.

It also had interesting ties to current events with its commentary on terrorism/rebellion/weapons of mass destruction. By the way, the science genius character realizing that he isn't priceless in developing some major device is fantastic. All of the movies with "only so-and-so can figure this out" are very disappointing.

The moral message of the movie was also very clear and well delivered.

I really enjoyed the movie overall and thought that it was a big step in the right direction. It was adventurous again, it was sometimes shocking, original, and most of all meaningful. A Force Awakens failed on all of those points. It's good to see a franchise movie that's taking a bit more risk than average. AFA was just like the new Star Trek films, shiny bling low-impact action movies that just happen to be set in space. Rogue One pushes far beyond to show the what drives the Rebellion in a world we know and love.

Despite the fact that I really liked the movie, it had some flaws:
- Tarkin face CGI
- Some of the acting in the first half.
- Tarkin face CGI
- Some of the cuts were really weird and the pacing felt off for portions of the first half.
- Tarkin face CGI
- Forest Whittaker just deciding to die instead of trying to escape.
- Tarkin face CGI
- A few unbelievable plot lines (thankfully most were minor). Like Cassian being sent to kill Galen for almost no reason, and then deciding not to for no reason, and then Jyn forgiving him surprisingly easily. How did she even know that he was trying to kill her father?
- Tarkin face CGI
- Does every Star Wars movie need to have a father character die? Why didn't Cass follow orders when he heartlessly killed someone else in his first scene?
- Tarkin face CGI
- Heavy handed political messaging.
- Tarkin face CGI
- Said "hope" too many times.
- Tarkin face CGI
- You can just push Star Destroyers that easily?
- Tarkin face CGI
- The word "Stardust"
- Tarkin face CGI
- Too many random worlds introduced that you don't have the time to get invested in.
- Tarkin face CGI
- Too much awkward fan service.
- Tarkin face CGI
- Darth Vader's voice sounded off.
- Tarkin face CGI
- Some of the dialogue was really terrible.
- Tarkin face CGI

loading replies

9 replies

@jared I'm confused... With regards to Rouge One; A Star Wars Story... so, what your saying is that your favorite part of the movie was the Tarkin face CGI???

@jared Lists literally tons of flaws, still rates 8 out of 10. trakt in a nutshell TOPKEK

@jared It bothers me irrationally that you call it A Force Awakens. It's actually "The", not "A". Everything else, totally respectable.

As for pushing the Star Destroyer, it was disabled by ion cannon fire from the Alliance Y-Wings. It wasn't obvious unless you're a Star Wars fan.

@jared So, how would you explain Tarkin's absence then?

8

OPReply by jared
VIP
EP
9

@iammarth All of those flaws don't compare how great it feels to have an epic new Star Wars movie instead of a standard issue J. J. Abrams generic sci-fi.

@bestivus Oops for the name. I saw this a second time and they do mention that. It still isn't clear how the ion cannons are that strong in this scenario. It's worth it for the awesome effect though.

@glamhoth One word: recast. Wayne Pygram looked the part in Episode III.

@jared "Oops for the name. I saw this a second time and they do mention that. It still isn't clear how the ion cannons are that strong in this scenario. It's worth it for the awesome effect though."

You should have played the X-Wing/TIE-Fighter games. It was a bit fast paced (not all shown, but said in dialogs) - true, but the rebels shot/opened a flight corridor, then the bombers could fire multiple ION-Torpedos, StarDestroyer disabled, then trying to move it... - a tactic which will not work often to this perfection - and some luck.
Like the whole Battle, the intention of the movie was to show that there was not 1 or a little group of heroes which stole the death star plans. Everyone single one from the rebel community - on the planet, in the ships, till the last rebel guard with his pistol - had an equal part on reaching the goal - giving their own life without questioning and simply doing what's right for the sake of all. The rebels "won" through a chain of events not a single character could have foreseen.

@jared I found the Tarkin face CGI to be really great. And it would have been more unbelievable if they hadn't done it. He was the major actor when it comes to the first Death star. They literally had to do the cgi, if they wanted to include important scenes from within the Death star.
It's a nice touch. :)

@jared - Princess Leia face CGI

@jared Just to respond to your point above, about how Jyn knew he was going to kill her father: there were context clues for her to infer from, Chirrut asking if Cass looked like a killer, due to the dark force surrounding him, and K-2SO stating his gun was configured as a sniper. It's a bit of a stretch for her I suppose, but I don't think its necessarily unreasonable for her to guess that, given who her father was. Totally agree about the rest of the plot lines though, and overall really fantastic review.

Loading...