All Comments about...

Black Christmas 2019

It's a perfectly average PG-13 horror flick. Middling, but not particularly bad or good, with some good moments thrown in here and there. But because it has an all female primary cast and is made by a largely female production team, and dares to be overtly feminist and touch on topical issues surrounding rape culture and toxic masculinity, some of the other commenters on here feel the need to write outright sexist diatribes and have to bend over backwards to read an "anti men" message into a film that has none. Sad and predictable. Nothing the film outright states or implies about sexism is untrue.

(And no, this film does not claim that "all men are rapists". That's a gross misreading of the film, and directly rebuked by the text - not even the subtext, the TEXT. The main characters specifically say they do NOT believe this at one point, and the biggest male role that is not overtly antagonistic is on the girls' side. If your mind hasn't been poisoned by alt right nonsense and conspiracy thinking, you can see that.)

loading replies

I love how they so subtly crafted the pro feminism and anti toxic masculinity narrative into their story. You really had to read between the lines, and think carefully to pick up the narrative.

At least they didn't make the entire story revolve around the feminist narrative, and completely disregard actually making a good story.

loading replies

“Did you just 'Not All Men' me?”

Freaking hilarious. And yes, that's a line from the movie.

Interesting fact: This movie was shot in June 2019 and finished in July 2019. According to IMDB, some scenes in the film were shot in only one take, and ad-libbed, without a competed script.

It painfully shows.

The script for this movie felt like it was written by Twitter with no subtlety in sight. Putting the "message before the story" is already a sign that this movie was destined to fail horribly.

Some of the acting and line delivery was terrible, which is where the "one take" thing is transparent. I wouldn't even call them “characters” in the movie, as they were merely mouthpieces.

This remake is so bad that the 2006 remake suddenly looks great. Avoid at all costs unless you like shitty movies.

loading replies

prior to watching it, i thought, it can't be as bad as everyone says...after watching it, it definitely can be as bad as everyone says. there is no endearing quality i can think of, in this movie. if anything, it makes me appreciate the 2006 remake, which really put additional perspective on how awful this 2019 version actually is!

loading replies

I....I have...such...mixed feelings about this movie. The action was good, even if the story was a bit slow at times. But they should have NEVER presented this as a remake because it is clearly not. It's more similar to Sorority Row (2009) than what it's supposed to be loosely based off of. If you don't think of it as a remake, it's okay. Not fond of the overly 'womyn good men bahd' message it tries to send and the characters and dialogue are atrocious but...decent action and okay plot twist if you take out the sexism involved.

loading replies

Pretty terrible movie. There's not anything scary and tries to say something but doesn't do a good job.

loading replies

Black Christmas isn’t so much a horror movie as it’s a “toxic masculinity” allegory. After pulling a prank on the AKO fraternity the girls of the MKE sorority find themselves being picked off and hunted by mysterious men in black cloaks and masks. Featuring Imogen Poots and Carl Elwes, the cast isn’t too bad, but they’re stuck playing rather cliché stereotypes. And the film just won’t let up on the Me Too politics. It fact, it seems to forget that it’s a horror film; as most of the kills take place off-screen or are cut away from – denying the audience the blood and gore that they’ve come for. Incredibly disappointing, Black Christmas is a jumbled mess that’s more concerned with knocking the patriarchy than delivering scares.

loading replies

While the feminist survivor narrative was appreciated, the twist completely undermines the tone and was just stupid.

Only related in name to Black Christmas.

loading replies

Pure trash. Given a different title this is still trash but at least it wouldn't bank on the supposed name of "Black Christmas". So many strange decisions made during this film and the strangest is the title. The third act is screenwriting incompetence at its highest point.

loading replies

One of the worst Christmas horror movies

loading replies

The second "loose" remake of "Black Christmas" is a bloodless slasher with no sense of horror or suspense. The sorority's relocation to the Blumhouse was definitely not worth it. While there are definitely some interesting themes in the movie, the execution is poor and may even end up hurting the cause a bit. Terribly written dialogue, some questionable performances (Cary Elwes! ), and a really stupid twist do the rest. At least Imogen Poots plays the lead role, whom I always like. However, even she can't save this movie from absolute boredom.

loading replies

I remembered watching this and hating it when it came out. Couldn't remember why and pegged it to be because im a huge fan 9f the original. Watched it again last night. Started off pretty good. Then figured I had to be wrong. Until...the black ooze. And then I thought, oh yeah...that's why. :rolling_eyes:

loading replies

Meandering social commentary disguised as a horror movie. This is not “Night of the Living Dead”, a thought provoking and satisfying horror movie. No! The bad guys are J Crew models (sorry for the obscure reference…I’m old), the good guys are “betas”, and You’ll figure it all out in 15 minutes tops!

loading replies

Finest twitter politics on display.

loading replies

I was cheering the girls women on the whole time. I'm very glad they didn't kill off any black characters either.

loading replies

how do you turn a horror movie into an after school teen movie? Brutal.

loading replies
6

Shout by Jim222001
VIP
6
BlockedParent2020-12-09T23:04:41Z— updated 2020-12-11T23:57:57Z

A psycho killer secretly lived in a sorority house in the original and the 2006 remake. From the trailers you can tell this is nothing like that.
It is a watered down girl power remake that is PG-13 for gods sake. Nothing against girl power. It is a step in the wrong direction though. For the slasher genre. If every girl is the final girl.
The first remake was even more brutally violent than the original. This movie is nothing like them. Just uses the Black Christmas name to sell tickets. Despite a Mean Girls rip-off singing scene. Not much of it even feels like a Horror Christmas movie.

loading replies

Second remake of the seventies chiller is both timely and ridiculous.

loading replies
3

Shout by Chris
VIP
EP
5

“You messed with wrong sisters!”
- Kris

Different title and I might have liked this. The homage to “Exorcist III” Was cool and it was shot very well. This is not “Black Christmas”.
:cat2::snowman2::bow_and_arrow:

loading replies
Loading...