All Comments about...

Hacksaw Ridge 2016

Yikes. Idk how I didn't notice this was directed by Gibson until after I wasted my time watching it - but big surprise, there's not a single person of color in the film, even when they were in that war. It's really insane. And dont tell me "there were Japanese people". Yes. Of course. There had to be - and I'm guessing he was at his limit for non-white characters ‍♂
The story is interesting enough. Maybe I'll check out the documentary or something - but tbh, just like another reviewer here, I think it was less about the religious thing and more about the thing that happened with his family. Just a guess. It seems way more plausible.

loading replies

Can't remember the last time a movie made me cry this much. Such a powerful movie, with great scenes, romance, laughter, tears through sadness and joy. I can't say I've seen a lot of war movies, but this one really opened my eyes, very well directed with great actors. I can't get over how strong this movie was, oh my god my face is still puffy and I feel so emotionally drained thinking about every person who has ever gone to war, either died fighting for what they thought was right or coming back and having to deal with losing so many friends and most having to live with PTSD. Wow, what a movie.

loading replies

Simply beautiful...
What a man he was!
God bless your soul Doss.

loading replies

I'm not sure how and why a movie, in which the main character's strongest believe is not to kill people, could celebrate the killing of people so much.

While this movie did have some clear "the terror of war" scenes, the finale did exactly what I've come to expect of Hollywood movies, glorified the "good guys" (soldiers), their weapons, and their belief in killing the enemy to defend their values.

I know that the movie is based on the accounts of the survivors, so I won't argue for inconsistencies. However, regarding if killing people is supposed to be right or wrong, the convictions and beliefs of the main character seem half-hearted to me. His past, as shown in the film, suggests his unwillingness to use a weapon is rooted more in a high sense of guilt over violent outburst against family members than his religious beliefs. Otherwise, I'd suggest he might have reacted more strongly to all the other people killing around him.

loading replies

My father was a Corpsman (medic) like Doss and he has always yearned for a film to portray what they go through. What is most remarkable about this film is that they actually had to tame some of the heroics as they thought the truth would have been too unbelievable. My father said that if you were only ever going to see one war movie, this should be it.

loading replies

Most of Second World War movies are inspired by the war in Europe, so you know the cruelty of the european side of war. With Hacksaw Ridge, prepare yourself for Okinawa.

I really love war movies, in fact I really love WW2 movies. I've watched a lot of them. And since Saving Private Ryan, none had made me feel like this movie. Powerful, inspiring... Really, really great!

loading replies

this has by far been the most unrealistic and exaggerated war movie I've ever seen. Actually a disgrace to this guys legacy.
Also, bad CGI and wrong casting choices

loading replies

An incredibly moving, exhilerating and engaging film, with amazing set-pieces, impeccable direction and staggering performances, perfectly portraying the gritty reality of war and the importance of staying true to oneself.

The plot progresses in an effective manner, giving the viewers time to relate to the character, which helps make the film and it's story much more impactful and engaging.

The gritty and violent action set pieces, which are discomforting at times, felt authentic and perfectly portrayed the brutality and ferocity of war.

The film also sheds light on the psychological affect of war on the ones that are involved, portraying a tragic reality of many homes.

Lastly, the film wouldn't have been as engaging and entertaining, had it not been for Andrew Garfield's incredible portrayal of the hero, Desmond Doss.

loading replies

An inspirational true story. In this age of fictional superheroes, Desmond Doss beats them all; a credit to the men he served with, and a credit to God. Mel Gibson directs his finest film in an age, telling a story that glorifies the human spirit, and not the violence of war.

loading replies

Overrated. Better to watch a documentary instead.

loading replies

Cast 9/10
Storytelling 9/10
Characters 8/10
Video Prouduction/Cut 9/10
Environment 4,5/5
Conclusion 4,5/5
=88% - 4% First Quater of Film was little bit cringe
+ 5% For Real Storytelling
=89%

loading replies

The movie is as good as the hype - this was an amazing story of courage and duty.   I was also blown away but Mel Gibson's ability to direct a movie - I thought he did a fantastic job.  

I often have a hard time watching the "based on a true story" movies because the whole time I am watching them I am wondering how much of it is actually true.  From my limited reading of other people's research the guts of the story are true.  In fact, his last scene in the war was even more fantastic than what was portrayed in the film (apparently Gibson thought that audiences wouldn't buy it).  I also found it very interesting that he was in fact pro-war but anti-gun but that's a conversation for another place.  

Finally, this was a fantastic film to see in 4k.  

follow me at https://IHateBadMovies.com

loading replies

Truly sensational, I can't describe how brilliant the screenplay and writing was. May God give peace to your soul Doss. Amen!

loading replies

Just got a new favourite war movie! Absolutely masterpiece!

loading replies

I didn't manage to get further than 14 minutes into this movie. The first part with the young brothers and family was quite awful (bad acting, uninspired writing) and then I tried to endure Andrew Garfield and a nurse doing some meta-awkward (pretending to be awkward in a cute way, but doing it awkwardly) love at first sight romance thing, and I couldn't stand the outlook of two full hours of equally bad movie making. And if I didn't know before (I should have, after seeing the Spider-Man crapboot), I now know to avoid any movie starring Andrew Garfield.

loading replies

this movie is simply a masterpiece, in addition to already having a beautiful story for being based on real events, it is a beautiful adaptation of a real event, not making you feel bored or boring, the film is a great tribute to everything that happened there and to everyone who died in the war, and everything is even better with Andrew Garfield who always gives a show of acting, this film is beautiful, it is incredible, it is sad, it is wonderful, and the war scenes, it is simply one of the best I have seen in any other film, it makes you feel the pain of war, as it is bad, how it hurts, how it hurts for those who are fighting in the war, and even for people's families, this movie is just incredible. Rest in Piece, Desmond T. Doss

loading replies

As a veteran myself it’s not often that a war movie triggers my emotions, this one did. Amazing :thumbsup:

loading replies

absolutely brilliant film dont usually watch war films but this was amazing

loading replies

The more I thought about this movie after I watched it the more I disliked it. Piss poor pacing, useless and uneven scenes, absolutely no characters developed besides the unrelatable main and his abusive father. Typically in war movies you feel some compassion or bond between some hero going against unsurmountable odds, but I just couldn't like the guy. As the movie lingers on it gets more and more unrealistic and that's when the wheels fell off for me.

loading replies

Shout by Deleted

Hacksaw Ridge is easily one of the best war movies we've gotten in recent years. Mel Gibson knows this genre as well as anyone and he delivers an emotional and incredible true story with great characters and amazing action. Andrew Garfield really anchors this film and gives the best performance of his career by a long shot. The same goes for Teresa Palmer. Then you get excellent supporting performances from Sam Worthington, Vince Vaughn, Hugo Weaving and Luke Bracey. I think this movie is a Best Picture competitor if the Academy can put Gibson's past comments behind him and its going to be one of the most significant and most memorable movies of 2016.

loading replies
8

Shout by CinemanicBonkers
BlockedParent2017-02-01T00:51:42Z— updated 2017-02-02T15:59:54Z

A war movie that deserves to be in my top films. Now Mel Gibson knows how to make a good war movie since his other classic work "We Were Soliders.' I was truly Impressed with this master piece. A great picture. I've never enjoyed a war movie has much as I've enjoyed this one. A well made film indeed. A beautiful story. Very powerful. At times it will get you right in the feels and other times you feel like you're on the war ground with them. I love the true story behind it, a very inspiring story. If I had a hat, It would come off for him. A great performance from a super cast! God bless him!

loading replies
10

Shout by Adecool
BlockedParent2017-02-04T19:34:44Z— updated 2017-05-13T14:11:49Z

This movie was incredible. I've never seen warfare portrayed in such an up-close and personal way, with so much attention to detail when it comes to brutality. The plot was perfect. The first act lacked any action but was still incredibly engaging thanks to how refreshing the main character was. Seeing him struggle to earn trust from his family and comrades because of his beliefs made for some good drama.

By the second act, we are taken straight into the battlefield and remain there until the very end without cutting in and out of the fight to focus on boring sub-plots. And the main character's unique emotional standpoint allowed for many impressive scenes of bravery and teamwork. Best war movie i've seen so far.

loading replies

Mel Gibson knows what he's doing when it comes to war movies.

Also, Andrew Garfield is fuck!ng amazing.

★★★★★★★★

loading replies

A biopic profiling Desmond Doss, a soldier in WWII who went into the front lines as a medic in Japan without a weapon, on religious grounds.

Hacksaw Ridge comprises of two excellently staged battle sequences showing the true horror of war. Comparisons to Saving Private Ryan are apt, at least in a technical sense.

The rest is all preachy Hollywood fluff and padding that inspires absolutely nothing in the audience. Garfield’s performance is solid but the script is so clunky and heavy-handed that he’s a wasted asset when he’s not saving lives. Gibson could have cut straight to the battle sequence; we’d have saved half an hour and lost nothing but meandering backstory.

I don’t want to end on a bum note because the tent-pole scenes that hold up the film definitely make it worth a watch, and there’s no denying that once the wheels get turning Hacksaw Ridge is absolutely gripping stuff.

PS: Being the flamethrower guy in a WWII film is the same as wearing the red shirt in Star Trek.

benoliver999.com/film/2017/04/21/hacksawridge/

loading replies

This movie is simply amazing. Portraying the horror of war while honoring the sacrifice and courage of those who endured hell on earth so that others did not need to. Be prepared for an amazing emotional roller coaster.

loading replies

I have mixed emotions about this film. On one hand it is a story told from an unusual perspective. It is a story about choosing life in the midst of the most brutal death. There is a pervasive message to the film, an unsung hero, a great romance. On the other hand, it is extremely violent, fitting the reality of battle. And although it highlighted the heroic nature of the principle character, I'm not sure it resolved the moral question. I walked away with unresolved question about it's principle ethical dilemma. (It did, however, force the viewer to think.). Andrew Garfield, Teresa Palmer, and Sam Worthington were excellent (all non-Americans playing Americans without a glitch). I give this movie a 7 (good) out of 10.

loading replies

One of the best movies I have watched lately based on actual events (https://trakt.tv/users/manu101/lists/based-on-actual-events)

loading replies

A truly powerful movie that makes you see the terror of war, it's supidity and the bravery of people. I'm speechless and emotionally agitated.

loading replies

The fact that it's based on actual events makes it a whole lot more intense, now I see what all the hype is about. Great movie

loading replies

Goes into my All time best movie Collection - One of the best war movie made in recent times. All credits to Mel Gibson for recreating the real effect & emotions through his script and Andrew Garfield for enacting the role of Desmond Doss so perfectly. I couldn't imagine a better fit than him to this role. The movie is so good that one will neglect the factual errors during the watch (provided you have read the history before watching the movie). Rest all is good.

loading replies

This was a long one but it didn't need to be in my opinion. The first hour of the movie was character development but once those battle scenes begin man are they brutal and intense. The first hour felt like Rudy and the second felt like Saving Private Ryan. A lot of it felt unrealistic until you learn it's based on a true story. It's worth watching at least once for those battle sequences.

loading replies

finaly i see one of the best movies like i uesd to see old days .. amazing story .. deserve 10 of 10 for sure .

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

The movie was exelent loved it the most realistic movie ever.

loading replies

great great great!!! desmond knows humanity

loading replies

An absolutely brilliant film, made even better as it's based on a true story

loading replies

It really was a powerful watch. Garfield slayed it and all involved told a great story that deserves the big budget treatment. Emotional to say the least and I shed a few tears. I was surprised I liked Vaughn in his role as well.

loading replies

Awesome movie. Even if only 10% is true, what hero Desmond Doss was.

loading replies

I don't know how much accurate it was but this was a pretty good war drama, not perfect but good. I believe that it needed some tweaks here and there to make this a solid 8. Something was off during the first part. The battle was good. Garfield gave a career performance that can lead to an Oscar nomination.

loading replies

A great film! The war scenes are very well produced, conveying the brutality and showing how war can change people permanently. This leads us to reflect and be sad about current events, such as the war in Ukraine, knowing that there are people who are suffering experiences similar to those portrayed in the film, in the current century.

loading replies

A strangely wholesome film when you consider the nature of war and everything that comes with it. A great film with an inspiring message for anyone who can stomach the graphic aspects of war. In general, war is an assault on everyone's convictions and I appreciate the humanity of this story being told, first of all because what Private Doss did was amazing, but secondly because it revealed a truth within everyone, not just Desmond. Those men in the film and any that watch it, have to wrestle with their character and who they will become from the choices they make.

I believe this was an honest film that captured a story worth telling and did it in a sensible and respectful way. A must see movie for young men coming of age, especially father's with their sons (13+).

loading replies

What a man - Ghandi 2.0.

If you ever need to show someone with an obsession for masculinity the power of compassion: this. This is what they need.

loading replies

NUMBER 1 FAVORITE MOVIE OF ALL TIME!!!!!

loading replies

One of the most emotional movies i have ever seen. Made me cry a lot. However I feel that the ending was a bit too rushed. The movie could have greatly benefited from an extra 20 minutes at the end.

loading replies

Hacksaw Ridge is an excellent movie based on the incredible true story of Desmond Doss and a tribute to his courage and determination in the face of adversity. The cinematography in Hacksaw Ridge is phenomenal, with Gibson's direction bringing a level of authenticity and emotional depth to the story that is truly remarkable. The battle scenes are intense and brutal, and the movie doesn't shy away from the tragedy of war. Overall, Hacksaw Ridge is a must-watch for anyone who loves a good war movie based on a true story.

loading replies

THE BEST MOVIE THERE IS.

loading replies

One of the best war movies. Awesome action scenes.

loading replies

Hacksaw Ridge is a stirring and heart-wrenching biopic of a war hero cum medic who refused to wield a weapon. Mel Gibson's depiction of the film has an excellent production value, a profound and earnest performance by Andrew Garfield, and a true story that effectively illustrates the horror of the Battle of Okinawa. The uplifting narration and inspiring finale make it a compelling war film to watch.

War films all look the same, you see tragedy, gore, and heartbreaks of lost soldiers but a film like Hacksaw Ridge doesn't come too often. An inspiring biopic of an American Medic who saved 75 lives in WWII. The first half film focuses on the life of Desmond while the second half moves to the battlefield. Andrew Garfield's honest and superlative performance is the best thing about the film along with the blatant war set-pieces. A war film where you focus less on the action and more on a person who is rescuing and saving injured soldiers itself depicts the bravery of Desmond Doss. A Must Watch.

Check my page
www.instagram.com/stream.genx

loading replies

Could throw away first half of the movie except for unexpected fight between brothers, honestly did nothing for background characters even through it should have. It was going through motions, routine cliches with no emotional depth. Bonding didn't work, scenes of hatred didn't work. BUT!
All the stuff on the battlefield did, including acting, friendship, dialogue looking at you Vince Vaughn brutal almost body horror scenes one could argue one step away from turning into torture porn.
I guess it was unfair to expect new "Apocalypto", but it still a mixed bag of a movie even without high expectations.

loading replies

Absolutely amazing film! The only two problems I have here is that a few scenes seemed like they would have been better placed as a cut scene in a Medal of Honour video game rather than a feature length film and my main disappointment is the corniness of the romance at the beginning. Apart from that this film was amazing.

loading replies

A war film. With guns. And explosions. And stuff.

loading replies

War is hell, but sometimes there will be angel even over there...

loading replies

From Mel Gibson comes the World War II drama Hacksaw Ridge. Based on a true story the film follows conscientious objector Desmond Doss as he fights to be allowed to serve as an Army Medic and ends up playing a pivotal role in the Battle of Okinawa. Starring Andrew Garfield, Hugo Weaving, Sam Worthington, Teresa Palmer, and Vince Vaughn, the film has an impressive cast that delivers some strong performances. And as usual, Gibson does an incredible job at showing the gritty reality of war. The writing is also especially good; exploring such themes as adhering to one’s religious convictions and the personal toll that violence takes. An extraordinarily compelling story about faith and heroism, Hacksaw Ridge is a powerful film.

loading replies

Very well made. Sometimes horrific but that was the reality of it. I don't typically like movies about war but this was a great movie.

loading replies

The fact that it's a true story makes it difficult to dispute the reality of the story. Reading a bit about medics in World War 2 shows that medics weren't required to carry weapons so it's curious that it came down to a Court Marshall proceeding for the other soldiers to leave him be and get on with the job. That said, it really is a remarkable story.

loading replies

excellent,true story which ie very hard to believe. Great

loading replies

A 10/10 rating is a huge understatement for this movie. This was a fantastic movie if not my most favorite movie of all time. At the moment. Anyone who didn't like it, let alone love it, is an idiot.

loading replies

What Doss did is pretty incredible tbh. Nice movie

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Wow warmed my heart. What a man. I think when he asked, the good lord gave him strength for 1 more man. Made me cry as well,several times.
Thank you DOSS.

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Loved it! It did everything right, from the main character and the rest of the cast's developments to the war action. The story is great and the way it deals with its themes while developing its characters in the same time is very captivating as well. If you're a fan of war movies, you're bound to like it.

loading replies

I'm so touched with this movie. Kindness will never end.

loading replies

Amazing movie based on an incredible story. Moviemaking at its finest. We need more films like this one.

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Para mi, la mejor película del 2016... Tremenda!!

loading replies

one of the best i ever watched

loading replies

Very good movie. Mel Gibson killed it directing and the whole cast killed it acting. A masterpiece.

loading replies

Desmond Doss, a true hero.

loading replies

Absolutely amazing film made even better that it's a true story, 99% of people will love this movie

loading replies

A Must watch absolutely brilliant, what a hero he is stunning and powerful.

loading replies

Mel Gibson's biblic representation of the Pacific War

loading replies
6

Shout by Deleted

First half of the movie was awful I had a feeling that I was watching some love story movie and I almost stopped watching.

loading replies

"With the world so set on tearing itself apart, it don't seem like such a bad thing to me to want to put a little bit of it back together".

It's amazing to think what Desmond Doss did. A great hero who kept his beliefs in doing good and not touching a gun in an environment of complete destruction and death.

Mel Gibson is back at directing after "Apocalypto" and does an amazing job. The man knows pretty well how to direct action scenes.

Among so many good performances, this is Andrew Garfield's movie. He was brilliant.

This film made me feel proud of the human race.

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

I gotta admit, I was not too interested in watching this. But I had to see what all the awards was about. The story line of Desmond Does (Andrew Garfield) not wanting to touch a gun & serve in WWII. I did not realize this was a true story. He wanted to be a medic, on the front lines. I was amazed at the whole movie. Mel Gibson is Suberb director! I definitely recommend this movie!

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Mel Gibson Made a Truly Masterpiece.

loading replies
9

Shout by Deleted

Thank you for sharing this story with me... touched & inspired.

loading replies
10

Shout by Deleted

Second best movie of my life

loading replies

Um dos melhores filmes que assisti nos últimos dias.

loading replies

Fantastic. Another triumph of a war film. No surprise, coming from Gibson. Some of the most brutal sequences from the Warfield, but also pushing the uplifting message of sticking to your convictions.

loading replies
8

Shout by Deleted

QUE HINOOOOO VC QUER LA LA LAND?

loading replies

Truly Amazing. Must Watch, Fantabulous.

loading replies

Beautiful scenes, great story (which is a true story on the top of all)and a superbe new point of view on the war and the meaning of being in duty. Really worth it waiting the first hour for the characters to develop and for the movie to start the action, as it's split in two halves.

loading replies

Shout by Deleted

Hacksaw Ridge is a masterpiece.
Inspiring, brutal, beautiful - this movie has it all.

Mel Gibson is a fantastic director, and he proves it once again with this $42 million budget war epic.
Hope he'll do the Viking movie next.

loading replies

Desmond Doss heroically saved 75 men without using a firearm...in the sequel, he will save 150 using only a rape whistle

loading replies
Loading...