All Comments about...

Slaughterhouse-Five 1972

I never read the book so cant compare, but the movie is a masterpiece in editing.

loading replies

An extremely loyal interpretation of the classic Vonnegut novel, this skirts the issue of explaining its complicated premise by way of a quick typewriter scene. Seeing it on-screen somehow makes everything seem less surreal than it was in print, even when the scenery randomly shifts from a Nazi POW camp to a sharp, sparsely-decorated single room apartment on the surface of an alien world.

Really just a handful of loosely-related tales from the protagonist's life, it's four distinct scenes tied together by jarring moments of deja vú and a strange, out-of-step sense of humor. A curious adventure, if only due to the sheer absurdity of its most profound scenes, it fails to stand out in any other meaningful ways. It's more straightforward and matter-of-fact than the book, and lacks many of the wry grins and quirks that made the original work stand apart. What works in print doesn't always translate so literally to the screen.

loading replies
Loading...