A movie about a woman who falls in love with a man who has all the personality of an uncomfortable chair. Every time she sits on it, it hurts her, yet she keeps going back to it because it's her favorite chair. WTF?
Seriously, the whole movie hinges on her passionate love for this guy and I thought he was an extra for much of the film? Like that damn chair, I'm not buying it.
oh my, one of the most boring films I’ve ever seen
The Souvenir's intent to be a dispassionate and a secretive semi-biographical affair of a young female in 80s London maybe worked a little too well and completely left me alienated from the vulnerability that I think, is supposed to bind me to the film. Unfortunately, this made watching the movie excruciatingly dull and painful.
I know this film has been highly regarded but it didn’t do anything for me. The most interesting moment is when Richard Ayoade turned up with an highly uncharacteristic performance.
Where to start with this one. It’s odd. It has a deadpan, almost dour like delivery. It reminded me of a Yorgos Lanthimos film in terms of atmosphere and dialogue, crossed with the pace and tone of Christopher Nolan’s ‘Following’. It is a very sparse, one dimensional film that has little to no tension or action to speak of, and instead relies on a series of life lessons for the lead character Julie. The last half hour has an almost meta / documentary feel to it – and it’s at the point you realise that it is basically a Biography by Director Joanna Hogg that it all clicks. It's a film about a young female film director, directed by a female film director.
It’s at this point you begin to ask yourself – are we seeing a slice of life in the early 80s that the Director went through? Is she Julie? Is this film that we are actually watching – the result of that experience? Instead of making a film about a boy in Sunderland, Julie is told to relate more to her actual experiences, which will mean her work will have more of a connection to her. Her privilege, her ups and downs etc. So ‘Souvenir’ seems to be literally her tale of how the film came into being. Which is a rather brilliant concept. Right down to the painting called ‘The Souvenir’ – in which a young girl (also named Julie) carves the initials of her lover into a tree. The viewer then begins to understand and empathize with Julie about how she's perhaps at a turning point in her life and is as naive as she is.
I’d hesitate to recommend this film to anybody as it is probably a little abstract / obscure compared to your average movie. But it is one for those who like to be challenged.
a toxic relationship where the protagonists speak in a very affected way.
A film built on memories of the director that make it interesting, more than in the description of this dependency relationship, but in her gaze towards artistic creation. While the protagonist builds her film between documentary and fiction, the film we are watching looks like a documentary at the end (the "interviewed" mother). It is a deep insight into creative process, which makes us curiously await its sequel.
I really can't watch this ... I find it kitchen sink drama.
I liked that the film didn't spend a lot of time setting the backdrop of the film. In the opening sequence you get a feel for many of the main characters through their party conversations (or lack thereof). I thought it was really interesting and in some ways inspiring how the (fantastic) female lead kept trying to drag her love interest over the proverbial finish line. Again, very few conversations about their struggle. Her quiet and strong spirit really carried the movie and that alone made the film worthwhile.
follow me at https://IHateBadMovies.com or facebook IHateBadMovies
Honor is a great actress. Her acting alone makes the movie deserve those 7 hearts.
A little slow for me but some good performances and I was interested in their relationship.
Review by DeletedBlockedParentSpoilers2019-09-03T12:43:24Z
I think the very best films are those that are able to speak to us, without being showy, of the rhythms and undercurrents that underpin our own lives. Sweeping emotional climaxes have never appealed to me as much as slow-burning, subtle explorations of our relationships with ourselves and others. Joanna Hogg's The Souvenir contains no grand climax, no catharsis, no resolutions. Instead it flows, shifting direction, twisting ever so slightly, looping back on itself and moving on anew. From reading the reactions to it, some have objected to its lack of obvious plot or its intensely personal nature, but these are the qualities I found myself relishing.
It's beautifully shot, full of muted tones and the grain of 16mm, and the use of space and light are remarkable—the feeling of a cramped student flat is captured perfectly. We move constantly back and forward between the living room, the bedroom, the stairwell. When Julie and Anthony are out for dinner they're shot from a low position, just a table in amongst the others. Close-ups are rare and all the more impactful for when they do appear.
What resonated deeply with me is the sense of being in a relationship that clearly isn't healthy but has enough charm, enough life, in it that it seems as if there really is no alternative. I have had relationships like that, where my partner would be equally controlling and encouraging. I was young and impressionable and even after it became clear to everyone else that there was only one way things could end I clung to it. I understand Julie: I understand why she stays with Anthony and goes back to him and indulges him; I understand it when she apologises to him for his bad behaviour; I understand it when she begins to borrow money from her parents to fund his lifestyle, remaining wilfully ignorant of its realities. There are seldom great, dramatic ruptures in real-life relationships and so it is here.
The performances from all of the actors involved are astonishingly good. Hogg spoke about casting Swinton Byrne because she seemed uncomfortable in front of the camera, like an artist and not an actor. This has proved to work very well as Julie seems, genuinely, like a young woman who hasn't figured out who she is personally or artistically. Tom Burke's arrogant, golden-tongued Anthony has a sort of feline character to him, sly and charming and managing to convey much with just his eyes. He worms his way into Julie's life, setting boundaries and then breaking them, pushing her far beyond what any partner should have to do. He encourages her, cajoles her, bullies her and it fills the heart with despair to see the relationship go where he directs it. Richard Ayoade has a memorable cameo and Tilda Swinton is typically magnificent as Julie's mother—a highly-strung parent who gets 'shopping headaches' and makes Julie and Anthony sleep in separate rooms.
Hogg also spoke of her lack of desire to make a film about class and yet class is everywhere in The Souvenir. It's in the sets, the clothes, the accents. It's in Julie's desire to make films about dockworkers in Sunderland, shown disdain by working-class and bourgeois characters alike. It's in the family dynamics, the parties, the cheques that pay for the dinners. It hangs obliquely over everything, and while Julie is often quick to acknowledge her own privilege it is clear that she occupies a rarefied existence.
The film's close comes almost delicately, and without the sweep that might be expected from a lesser, more obvious picture. It made me feel a quiet, deep sense of loss that I'm still thinking about days later. I will come back to it, revisit it, think about it. That is what I want from cinema.