After a disturbing incident, a young couple move into a seemingly perfect home built in the 18th century. However, the building's close proximity to the site of the Lost Colony's disappearance and with horrific events happening at the house the couple start to sense something dark underneath the facade.
Matt and Shelby, an interracial couple, decide to move to North Carolina and get away from the big city for peace and quiet and to start a new life, until Shelby starts seeing strange things that haunt her day and night.
Matt and Shelby find a revealing videotape in a hidden cellar. Meanwhile, Lee's daughter Flora makes a new friend, and the mysterious events continue.
Nightmares become an inescapable reality as unique stories of people's lives in America reveal the astonishing power of the supernatural.
Scathach presents herself for the first time and reveals what she wants. However, Tomasyn and the ghost settlers have other plans.
The Millers attempt to escape the house with the help of an unexpected ally.
The producer of My Roanoke Nightmare decides to follow up his huge hit with a second season... putting the actors and their real-life counterparts in the same house during the Blood Moon, and seeing if Lee confesses to Mason's murder.
Chaos breaks out at the house as Audrey, Monet, and Lee try to escape through the secret tunnel. Meanwhile, Shelby learns why Matt came back to the house, and Agnes considers a career change.
Lee, Audrey, and Monet try to escape the Polks. Meanwhile, Shelby and Dominic are trapped by the ghosts in the house.
Three My Roanoke Nightmare fans pay a visit to the House, unaware that they've arrived at the worst possible time. Meanwhile, Lee and Audrey try to recover the camera, and a new visitor doesn't prove very helpful.