The gang goes an arcade and everyone's winning lots of tickets except Bloo. Bloo then becomes very interested in a prize that's 500 tickets: glow in the dark Dracula teeth. So Bloo wants them to give them their tickets so he can get one, but the others decided to collect all of their tickets and get a rubber elephant, which Bloo grows an obsession with later on. But when Frankie, who's holding the rubber elephant, goes to sleep, Bloo sneaks in and steals it. When he's playing with, it breaks. The only option is to go to the arcade and win 500 tickets to get another rubber elephant. Can he get the elephant before the others find out?