To prove to her roommate that her bad luck in love has nothing to do with the men she chooses, Jody decides to date every man she's ever rejected, starting with the guy she just passed on the street.
There was always something wrong with Bruce's face. Something missing. But, just in time for his date with Jody, he's got an amazing new addition. Meanwhile, Brooke tries to convince Jody to surprise Bruce with an amazing new subtraction of her own.
Helen and Ted wanted to have a threesome. They invited Jody, and she refused. Now, she's giving a chance to everyone she's ever rejected - even couples. Sadly, since that initial offer, Helen and Ted have suffered a messy break-up. But that shouldn't be a problem, should it?
Jody finally agrees to go on a date with Larry, the man who's been stalking her for years. She comes prepared, determined to make the night a good one for both of them.
Jody agrees to go on a date with the woman who asked her out months before, but she's not sure she's ready to get romantic with a lady. Luckily, her roommate Brooke has a plan to help her out.
Jody can't remember why she turned Tony down the first time he asked, and now that she's agreed to go out with him, she just can't shake the feeling that it must have been a pretty good reason.
Jody goes on a date with a gentleman who appears to have somewhat Victorian sensibilities. That is, until she calls him on it, and he sets out to prove her wrong.
Exhausted from a long, sleepless night, Jody goes on a breakfast date with a man whose emotional extremes aren't only exhausting, and irritating, but potentially deadly.
Jody goes on a date with a bad, bad boy. Hell Froze Over ends Season One with its strangest, and perhaps most disturbing, episode ever.