The first OVA is a re-enactment of the first chapter, where Negi first learns of his job as a teacher and is introduced to the students of Mahora Academy 2-A. It ends with profiles of the Baka Rangers (Asuna, Makie, Yue, Ku Fei and Kaede) as well as Ayaka. Asuna is the only girl in the class that doesn't have romantic feelings for Negi.
The second OVA is a re-enactment of the "love potion" incident of chapter 2, with profiles at the end of Nodoka, Konoka, the cheerleaders (Misa, Madoka, Sakurako) as well as Kazumi.
The third OVA is a re-enactment of chapter 13: Negi's Mahora tour with the Narutaki twins. The tour shows Negi to several of the students (Yuna, Akira, Chao, Satsuki, Satomi, Chizuru, Natsumi, Zazie) as well as others that he ends up missing (Sayo, Evangeline, Chachamaru, Chisame, Misora, Ako). After being chewed out by Haruna for completely skipping her, a final scene introduces Setsuna and Mana, keeping watch from something on campus.
Class 2-A meets its new teacher, who turns out to be a 10-year-old boy from Wales.
Asuna blackmails Negi to help her woo Professor Takahata; the class throws Negi a welcome party.
Negi makes Asuna a love potion that goes horribly wrong.
Negi continues to attempt to help Asuna get higher grades.
Chamo arrives at Mahora Academy intent on finding Negi a Pactio partner.
Evangeline starts her rampage against Negi.
Negi learns ninja skills from Kaede.
Evangeline challenges Negi to a battle; Chachamaru prevents Negi from winning.
Negi sets out to run an errand for the Dean with the Narutaki twins as his escorts.
Class 2-A battles in a dodgeball match against some girls who are also smitten by Negi's looks.
The girls create a homepage for Class 2-A on Negi's new laptop computer.
Negi and the Baka Rangers explore Library Island's basements for a magical book that will make the class dunces smarter for exams.
A stone golem traps the Dummy Force on Library Island.
A love potion mix-up leads to a misunderstanding.
Class 2-A visits Ayaka's mansion; Negi learns that all is not what it seems between Asuna and Ayaka.
Several of Negi's students hold a pillow fight in Mahora's old elementary school building.
Yue gives amusement park tickets to Nodoka and Negi.
Asuna contemplates confronting Takahata following Nodoka's confession.
Kazumi investigates a classmate named Sayo Aisaka.
A class trip to Kyoto turns into a hostage situation.
After a tumultuous first day in Kyoto, Negi, Asuna and Setsuna accompany Konoka back to her home.
Konoka and Setsuna reestablish their childhood friendship; Negi hones his magic skills with help from Evangeline.
On Asuna's last day she searches for an answer.
Negi does his best to lift class 2-A's spirits with preparations for the Cultural Festival.
Class 2-A scurries to get ready for their musical; Negi tries to bring Asuna back to life.
Evangeline is forced to divulge the magical truth to the entire class.