Paul, Star Schlessinger, Armond Mite, and Bigfoot talk about the broken debates. In "Make Sense," Dan Abrams talks via satellite about the issues with fantasy game gambling websites. Kristen Schaal talks about her views of the 2016 Presidential Election and takes part in "Wait, What?!" with Paul, Hot Dog, and Lady Weiner. Hannibal Buress talks about his special coming up on Netflix, his opinions on the political debates, and the effects of the 2015 El Niño. Paul, Star Schlessinger, Armond Mite, and Hot Dog talk about their "Wishues" (short for wish issues) as part of the 2016 Presidential Election.
In the second special, Paul F. Tompkins does "Shut Up the Vote 2015" with Star Schlessinger, Barry, and Dwayne Johnson revolving around Ben Carson's presidential campaign. Patton Oswalt announces his candidacy for President and talks about what he'll do when he becomes President while answering questions from Barry, Star Schlessinger, and Dwayne Johnson. Hot Dog talks about his trip to Politi-Con while showing footage of his interview with Ted Lieu. Paul gets a call from Donald Trump only to learn that he is talking to archive recordings of him. The "NYSU Vault" is opened so that they can look back to an older version of the show Mr. Carruthers, Mrs. Bramblecorn, and a faceless hot dog. Paul, Star Schlessinger, Dwayne Johnson, and Hot Dog talk about who to shut to in 2016.
Host Paul F. Tompkins and his supporting cast of puppets tackle the tough issues including Sarah Palin, gun control, and iguanas. Colin Hanks (Life in Pieces) talks ISIS and Cenk Uygur (The Young Turks) has harsh words for Peyton Manning.
Host Paul F. Tompkins and his supporting cast of puppets tackle the key issues including the Middle East, prison reform, and potatoes. Bassem Youssef (The Daily Show) puts his soul on the line and Adam Conover (Adam Ruins Everything) faces death.
Host Paul F. Tompkins and the panel tackle issues including Taylor Swift and immigration. Comedian Jen Kirkman doesn’t feel the bern and a bird flummoxes NASA engineer Bobak Ferdowsi.
Host Paul F. Tompkins and the panel take on issues including The X-Files and gas prices. Bobby Moynihan (SNL) dunks voter apathy, Rhea Butcher tackles football, and writer Joel Stein explains Bernie Sanders.
In this special episode, Al Madrigal guest hosts and Hot Dog makes out with Whoopi Goldberg on the Oscars red carpet. Al and the puppets take on privacy, the SCOTUS vacancy, and Damn Daniel.
Host Paul F. Tompkins and the panel take on issues including funnel cake, the female vote, and more. Tony Hale speaks frankly, Mary Lynn Rajskub comes clean, and author Reza Aslan skewers Donald Trump
Host Paul F. Tompkins and the NYSU pundits take on Donald Trump. Thomas Lennon (The Odd Couple) reveals a shocking secret and humorist John Hodgman talks Trump’s downstairs parts. Plus correspondent Brianna Baker hits the streets of L.A.