When Kim (Julia Voth) starts dating Danny (Randal Edwards), he seems too good to be true – a successful lawyer, charming, and single. Then, she discovers he’s already committed – to his two older brothers, Sheldon (Harland Williams) and Ryan (Jay Malone). Will Danny ever grow up and be his own man? Or will Kim have to accept that his brothers are part of a “package deal”?
After his brothers make a terrible first impression and scare off his new girlfriend, Danny enlists their help to get her back - but Kim isn't sure this relationship is worth it if it really is a 'package deal'.
Kim feels left out of the brothers' "prank wars". Her attempts to join in go awry, but the brothers ultimately welcome her into the fold by making her the subject of an elaborate prank.
Danny and Kim's relationship is in jeopardy when he accidentally blurts out "I love you" during sex. His backtracking only makes it worse, especially once he realizes he really does love her.
When Kim starts monopolizing Danny's time, Sheldon and Ryan try to find her a friend in order to get Danny's attention back for an upcoming karaoke tournament.
Danny tries to make amends to a client he bullied as a child by giving him the world's best defense - but he's left on the hook when the client unexpectedly dies in the middle of the trial.
The mounting tension between Kim and his brothers leads Danny to spend his downtime with McKenzie in prison. Sheldon enlists Nikki as his model for a casket ad.
Danny's birthday present for Kim is stolen when Sheldon repeatedly uses Danny's apartment (and identity) to seduce morally dubious women. Ryan stakes out a jewelry store in hopes of meeting his ex-wife's new beau.
When Ryan's therapist moves out of town, Danny gets him a job at Kim's tea shop. But Ryan goes off the rails when he discovers the therapist is still in town - and lied just to get rid of him.
When Kim gets into an altercation with a masseuse at a day spa, Danny represents her at trial. Ryan meets his new therapist, Dr. Sydney Forbes, and finds himself very uncomfortable with her unorthodox style.
Sheldon has Kim train him to be a gentleman in hopes of winning back the girl of his dreams. Danny, nervous about accepting an upcoming award, tries out Ryan's new therapist.
When Sheldon lands a party-planning gig for an important Judge, Danny steps in to make sure everything runs smoothly. Ryan's new therapist falls for him and it threatens their professional relationship.
When Danny falls ill, Ryan and Kim compete over who can take care of him best. Meanwhile, Sheldon and Nikki are left in charge of Kim's teashop, which they turn into a profitable coffee-and-pizza joint.
When Ryan runs into Alison's best friend, Sheldon helps him look good by saying Kim is his girlfriend. But soon, the lie spirals out of control, forcing the gang to keep up the charade over the course of an entire dinner party - the success of which could have dire consequences for a very important trial.