Peppermint Larry refuses to give Flapjack and K'nuckles any candy unless they bring him candy wrappers to exchange for the treats. Selfishly, K'nuckles takes all of the candy for himself, breaking Flapjack's heart. He discovers Larry's true plans when trying to exchange more wrappers; the wrappers formed a map when put together leading to Candied Island. K'nuckles tries his best to regain Flapjack's friendship. He does this, but Flapjack destroys the wrapper that Peppermint Larry needed to get to Candied Island. Once K'nuckles explains all this, they forge the wrapper and trade it in. Peppermint Larry then attempts to use the map to get to Candied Island, but instead it leads to Pickled Island. He is still happy that he has his candy-wife with him; however, this changes when he sees her having an affair with a giant pickle.