They took quite a risk with the audience openly switching the main focus on Churchill. It definitely worked, adding more depth to the character and like the infamous painting, bringing the final strokes to what remain the best rendition of Winston Churchill we have ever seen on tv. But what make the episode unforgettable is the amazing timing, framing and editing of the final sequence. Simply a work of art.
Sometimes I'm amazed about how such mediocre movies can be pumped and overhyped for so little...I mean it could have almost been a decent action movie if it was a little bit shorter, and had at least one tiny bit of developing in the storyline beyond "cool machines driven by freaks chasing in the desert".. All in all beside a great costumes design and props what you are left with, is just some sort a giant shallow videoclip, with a great visual reworking of the post atomic imaginary introduced from the first Mad Max. Oh yes and plus some half naked models.
It's true, after all those useless blurry, hyperkinetic camera movements we got overdosed in the last decades, it's refreshing to see some more traditional shooting with a proper image composition...on the other hand Fury Road to (badly) counterbalance one good thing, need to add something really wrong, hence I have the feeling it will be remembered for one of the worst night photography seen since who knows when maybe the 70s...I mean blue filtering for the night sequences?! c'mon is that a joke?!...in the age of the uber ISO settings digital camera brought even to consumer market? Is really depressing to see so blatantly fake night scenes in a big budget movie...and for no imaginable reason.
I was about to let it go half the way, honestly I made it to the end just out of curiosity...not for the movie itself which became boring pretty soon, but because I was desperately looking for that special something that should have made this movie worth at least some of the praise I had read from audience and critics alike. Needless to say, there was nothing until the end...just you know, the desert...
Meh. Nice editing. The visuals are interesting though I'm not even sure how much is animated here, looks more like rotoscoping with some coloring on top. However the plot is really weak, and the central soft porn part is totally gratuitous and patched over the storyline...that actually makes the whole episode something like - I want to show some stripping girl with this cool design effects...mmh...let's pretend to build a story around it.
Pointless.
Watching this again 10 years later. Many things happened since, lots of tv shows came and went. Still this episode hold its place as one of the greatest season finale ever.
I have said it before and I have to confirm this again...Holden and Naomi remain the weakest characters (as they actually are in the book too) that when the plot puts them in the background like in this episode, the show works much better. In my opinion the tv version managed to fix some weaknesses of the books, so maybe screenplayers could have tried to make the story more collective and leave Holden and Naomi in a not too prominent position. The first season was kind of different since there was Miller around, a much more interesting character.
One thing's for sure, since her storyline took steam, Bobbie is totally stealing this show. She made Draper TV versione much more intense than her book counterpart.
Even without dialogues the first scenes of this episode are so powerful visually (which is probably the exact reason why they do not need dialogues), that just those few minutes alone already made this show an instant classic in the Star Wars mithology.
Straight from Chapter One of Cliffhangers Base Rules Handbook.
And still does the damn trick...
Team Steve-Dustin-Robin-Erica totally kick ass!
Now I'm an old Marvel comics geek so my opinion might not be completely unbiased I know. Still for that same reason I'm pretty critical about this show and sometime I feel like that is not written that well, though constantly saved by a truly amazing cast, and not only Matt, Foggy, Karen I mean. D'Onofrio too as Kingpin was simply great, but Berthal...oh boy...he delivered a truly unforgettable Punisher.
So, yes sometime screenwriting to me feels a bit lazy, like if writers know they can always rely on great cinematography and a top notch casting to patch everything up and make the whole thing work almost by itself.
But...whatever my opinion can be, you must give up to the fact that Frank Castle monologue was simply one of the best acting performance I have ever seen. Period. And god knows any actor would crawl on its knees to get the chance to play a role with a scene like that. Berthal hopefully will get other chances to show his acting skills again, but honestly sometime such things happen once in a lifetime. In a full long career De Niro had just one "Taxi Driver" mirror monologue. And who knows...it will be not impossible, but quite hard to get another Punisher monolgue like that. Good luck Mr Bernthal...
Well first off I need to say I have been in a total 'bromance' with Jake Gyllenhaal for few years now and biased as I might be, I think this is another movie he nailed just great. I love the subtle way he works to define his characters, how Lou looks gangly and with those big wide opened voracious eyes that are somehow a mirror of what is about to become...Jake has an amazing restraint in acting, especially in this age where tv shows formats brought an often over-dramatized style into storytelling and acting, so his way to sculpt his characters a little at a time manage to build a certain tension underneath that keep you focused on them even in ordinary set-ups and situations..and this approach to acting makes even more intense when those subtle underneath tension gets released like in the mirror scene.
Beside his performance I think Nightcrawler is a very good movie with some really great moments, and a central theme about what we as audience, have been accustomed to consider information and how morbid we grew about the appearance of what happens instead of the reasons or the facts itself.
Directing and photography are stellar, for what seems a well paced and balanced screenplay manage to mix introspection, storytelling and pure action even though there are few unfocused moments. The car chasing scene, considered how has been endlessly abused by movies, is just amazing with a fantastic edit and originality in choosing the point of view af a third spectator instead of the runaway or the chaser, which are the common storytelling perspectives we see in such scenes.
I was slightly disappointed in few aspects about how the plot develops in the last part. I would have liked a more open and thought provoking ending, the final interrogation and the closing scene looked a bit too predictable and not aligned with the overall tone of the story. A bit too 'didactic' in the purpose, probably to accomodate the so called general audience which always needs a proper wrap-up to get what the story is about. If it was up to me I would have ended the movie with the broadcasting of the last reportage for instance.
I gave it a 7, it may have rightfully deserved a 8, but you know the final always influence too much of a movie overall perception. It's somehow unfair even to me, but I can't help it.
Wow...three part Ogre storyline it's been simply awesome. I love how they are (re)building characters personalities true to the Batman mythology, just adding one layer at the time. I think this could be the greatest strenght of the show: just experiencing Bruce, Selina, Jim and all the main iconographic characters from the comic books evolving into..themselves!
Totally ninja. I mean, literally.
Wow...that was intense! I knew Eva Green was good, but after this show I would say she is nothing less than great. Beside that I think what really worked here around her stellar performance is the excellent characters development of the other ones, I mean even if is she obviously stealing the scene, if you really look into the storytelling aspect are the other characters actions and how do they realate to her situations that make the Whole episode work so good.
I'm not sure about the Frankenstein bit, it seemes a bit patched up and somehow break the tension, though of course it reminding viewers about his own ungoing sub storyline it could have been skipped to keep a more tighten story. Beside that I have liked that "bro" moment in the shooting basement sequence between Victor and Ethan.
Until this episode the 5th season lacked a certain spark for me, at least compared to the previous ones.
It is quite obvious that the space left by Ragnar, Rollo etc. that driven the early seasons and set the tone to the whole show, was getting more evident (despite the Seer telling the contrary to Lagertha in this episode) now that those storylines plots and sub-plots are completely behind.
But with this episode things are finally opening towards new angles and developments, mainly with Astrid change of position and obviously Bjorn finally in the Mediterranean introducing few interesting characters and situations. But there is alot more going on!
I have the feeling that this episode ,though at first glance lacking any real key events, represent a pivotal moment for almost all the main characters: the brotherhood triangle between Ivar, Hvitserk and Ubbe after a long stall, is now entering a new more interesting stage, Lagerta coming to terms with the shifting powers in Kattegat, the Floki physical and inner trip coming to a conclusion, Harald and Halfdan brothers fully taking their own different paths, Heahmund and Athelwulf alliance cracking under different ambitions and motivations.
Basically in a quite subtle and smart way, 'The Plan' is (ironically) bringing to the show exactly what the title suggests: the foundations plans on which all next storylines will develop.
Best episode so far in the second season! Honestly having read the original books, I still think the TV version is way better than the books. Overall my problem with the source material is that most of the main characters are somehow bland, though they improve a bit along the way.
The first season was basically held together by Miller alone, but the thing is that most of the Rocinante's crew can't really manage to keep the show engaging to me. That is why in my opinion The Expanse works at best, like in this episode, when manages to keep a collective narrative, balancing all characters point of view. They should use episode with this storytelling structure as blueprint reference for all the season.
Beside that...Bobbie character is spot on, much more intense and vivid than the books. Hats off to Frankie Adams.
And Cortazar...I was kind of puzzled when he was introduced since I couldn't really get his effective purpose to the story...well basically turned out being what Reinfield character was to Dracula in Bram Stoker book. He remind me so much Reinfield that feels like lifted from the book and shot in the space. Beside the vampire here is the Protomolecule... ;)
Oh boy. I'm about to die of 80s. And it's awesome!
The mood and settings in the Narkina Five scenes somehow managed to create the missing link between Thx1138 and Star Wars.
Wow...one of the worst storytelling I have ever seen in my whole life...this should be studied to show screenwriters how to not use flashback narrative and alternate timelines.
The most puzzling thing is how the production of a good show can so blatantly go off rail on so many things in just one episode.
At least now we have some relevant story backdrops about the main characters...still such elements have been introduced in the worst possible way.
..I've been clicking on the eleventh heart on trakt's rating for a couple of minutes at least...still it got only ten. This is so wrong...
I was willing and ready to see some minor or bigger changes adapting the books for the TV...but honestly with this last addition of the Flamekeepers, they definitely demolished the very basic dynamics on which the whole book original trilogy is pivoting.
Actually now I even get why they decided to split IT narrative function, in something like Judicial and IT.
And for no practical or creative reason, if not the one to push in certain themes that seem to be trending these days.
I think for anyone who loved the book, this is the the right moment to bail out from this show.
Or at least that is what I will do.
Is not bad for what it is, but seeing the meaning of something you know and love, bended and changed in something else..well is not nice and worth my time.
...it might be just me, because I do not even use sunscreens because of how much I hate the feeling of those squishy mushy slippery blobs...but this episode was the creepiest ever!
11/10 for Ben Stiller and Dan Erickson for making the best season finale ever since Ron Moore's Battlestar Galactica 'Kobol' s last gleaming'.
Now the thing is that the underworld street gang as idea itself works well, gives depth to a location like Mos Espa that otherwise would only be a familiar backdrop to move already known characters.
So ok, nothing wrong with what...but is the how not the what..that is really kind of puzzling...at best.
First off the design of those speeder-vespas is so blatantly wrong, and I mean in everything, they do not look like Star Wars tech, they do not fit in the context, they are even without considering the colors simply designed bad.
Since the standard visual design of Star Wars is always been based on the styles set by McQuarrie/Mollo/Chiang..I find incomprehensible if not simply unbelievable how come that those designs managed to survive from exploring ideas in pre-production up to actually shooting something so evidently wrong.
So my main problem is that those ridicolous speeders screaming "WTF" pulled my attention to a not so good gang characterization, which is another thing that doesn't fit well with the overall Star Wars style...it may have been slipped in the background if at least most of those characters screen time wasn't on such silly vehicles.
Then there are another couple of things in the overall tone that are starting to bothering me, I do not like personally and maybe is just me but to be honest do not even fit well with the character characterization and the general SW lore: Boba Fett is becoming a bit too incline to diplomacy. A bit too much and a bit too fast I would say.
I do understand this is the old Boba Fett but after going through some transformative experiences, from the bonding with sand people to the new role of "daimyo", which ok means he has to switch from the solitary bounty hunter mindset to a different one as ruler of a more complex and variable organization.
Ok, there's going to be some "politics" to deal with. Still this is or too rushed or just too broad in how is represented, because after all a character need to stay true to a given nature, otherwise it will loose its own peculiar traits and personality.
The other thing, and I'm afraid this is unquestionably the heavy hand of Disney, is the progressive pet-ification of animal-like creatures...which now reached even the Rancor.
That is definitely the nowadays typical Hollywood histeric industry reaction to the dumb online criticism that already came around with how the Boba Fett showed the treating of wildlife.
We live in horrible days for creativity and art...
That 'Brother Can You Spare a Dime' pairing was worth all the episode...
I read terrible things about this movie...so expecting the worst I had it sitting on my view list for a while. Then I finally decided to hit the play button, because afterall I liked much the basic idea, the look of the movie and well I'm quite a J-law and sci-fi fan. So you know...what could possibly go wrong? For once nothing, almost.
"Passengers", against all odds, is a very good movie. And the odds here were huge, beside average audience often shallow criticisms, telling a story with basically just two actors and one indoor set is a real challenge especially for a mainstream flick.
It could easily work as a theater play, but as a proper movie that's a whole different story. Interestingly from this point of view "Passengers" feels like the simpler cheesy (but smart) hybrid from two Duncan Jones sci-fi movies, that is "Moon" and "Source Code".
So let's the spoilers begins, yes there are few a bits too much of Hollywood pleasing twists, especially towards the end. Still the movie has its strenght, enough to survive those few "meh" moments, science fiction here becomes the frame and backdrop to tell something about the human heart. It's the kind of science fiction story that would have fitted properly in a Ray Bradbury anthology.
What is really great in this movie, and that objectively kept the whole thing together, are the never less than brilliant performances of Jennifer Lawrence and Chris Pratt supported by well written dialogues. Jennifer Lawrence has some pretty intense moments, even when the scripting seems to get a bit thin, she manages to keep her character true and vivid. The wide deserted interiors of the sets, mainly dominated by white colors, create even more focus on the acting. So again both Lawrence and Pratt did an amazing job, pretty much like a theater play stage, there isn't anything distracting or tricking the audience, in most scenes, most of the time the photography is tight and focused on the acting performance, so many good scenes don't even have/need dialogues but are built on physical acting, body language, looks and silent stares. That's proper acting and well beyond the average standard we are used in this genre of movies.
Don't bother too much about the bombastic Hollywood take on those final moments, and you will get a very good space romance drama, deep enough to leave you with something worth thinking after the closing credits.
Wow..the other Bruce is giving me the creeps... :D great acting for David Mazouz!
I think writers have been doing a good work shifting powers from the Ragnar character to Bjorn. Or at least after they made Ragnar a pivotal character, I like the way how now they are deconstructing him, as his values and the whole viking culture shifts through an era of huge changes. On the other side King Ecbert ways are mirroring again the same cultural changes from a different perspective and culture. The old ways are becoming..just old...and what we are seeing is that while someone is refuging in the past pretending that things will stay the same forever, some one else is struggling to deal with such changes though without any hint about what's coming next.
Holy shit...amazing episode! screenplay was so tight with all the back and forth in the timeline!
In retrospective this seriously risked to kill the whole franchise. That is how bad MI2 is, even as mindless action movie.
Only for Woo die hard fans.