Season 2

M. William Phelps

Self - Host

8 episodes

John Kelly

Self - Profiler

8 episodes

Kate Ryerson

Cathleen Thomas

2 episodes

Emily Stratten

Annamaria Phelps, Molly Bish

2 episodes

Peter Bertoni

Boyfriend

1 episode

Amber Gokken

Charlene Smith, Cheri Domingo

1 episode

Damien Carr

Killer 1

1 episode

Michelle Collins

Maggi Bish

1 episode

Peter Djordjevic

Killer

1 episode

Madeleine Levins

Kelly Disney

1 episode

Dave W. Phillips

Lead

1 episode

Karina Banno

Laura Miller

1 episode

Yasmin Horner

Jessica Cain

1 episode

Miranda O'Hare

Heidi Villarreal Fye

1 episode

Morgan Derera

The I-70 Killer

1 episode

Rohan Everingham

Male Cop

1 episode

Emma Mothersdill

Sarah Blessing

1 episode

Christian L. Scott

Lucretia Gullett

1 episode

Annick Rickenbach

Patricia Smith

1 episode

Victoria Morgan

Cassandra Lee Hailey

1 episode

Richard Adams

David Knobling

1 episode

Stephen Noad

Cop

1 episode

Jace Pickard

Daniel Lauer

1 episode

Jamie Vergan

Cop 2, Hunter Barry

1 episode

Neda Aslani

Ramona Wilson

1 episode

Persia Blue

Colleen MacMillen

1 episode

Yasmin Pegram

Young Colleen MacMillen

1 episode

Maha Wilson

Gladys Radek

1 episode