All Comments about...

The Plot Against America

Season 1

The only other David Simon show I've seen is The Deuce, but I already feel he excels more in that ambling, characters-and-details-over-plot mode (which I presume most of his works are) than this kind of faithful book adaptation. It creates a constant push-and-pull between diving into religion/politics/period minutia and forward narrative momentum, doing either no favor in the set-up episodes. As this alternative scenario gets grimmer though, the show becomes more gripping with each terrifying and realistic new step taken, leading to a great (and distressingly not that far-fetched) finale of overwhelming, potent apocalyptic doom.

MVP: Zoe Kazan. There's a long zoom-in shot of her on the phone, with intermittent sound of gunshots ringing nearby as background, that absolutely floors me with her mixed expressions of shuddering fear and resolute maternal strength.

loading replies
Loading...