Season 1

Nathan Wiley

Narrator (voice)

6 episodes

Rachel Rain Packota

Razakel

1 episode

Chandler Loryn

Melanie Wells

1 episode

Jason C. Paul

Sam

1 episode

Val Cole

Mary Kay Beck

1 episode

Will Conlon

Wade Ridley

1 episode

Staci Bouskill

Teresa McBain

1 episode

Jim Canale

Glenn Kallai

1 episode

Dawn Sadler

Anne Simenson

1 episode

Stephanie Valano

Marcy

1 episode

Jeremy Durgana

Detective

1 episode

Aveleigh Keller

Kacie Woody

1 episode

Shawn Devlin

Rick Woody

1 episode

Sidney Sholdice

Jessica Bradford

1 episode

Avery Laine

Samantha Mann

1 episode

Kye Deuters

Scott

1 episode

Curtis Desrosiers

Lt. Jim Barrett

1 episode

Jamie Tarantini

Amanda Howard

1 episode

Anna-Sigga Nicolazzi

Self - ADA, Brooklyn, NY

1 episode

Suzanne Pratley

Kathleen

1 episode

Brendan Nasr

Alex

1 episode

Julia Flood

Ashley Smith, Lauren Gash

1 episode

Sarah Jean Hodkinson

Alisa Betts

1 episode

Sarah Lynn Strange

Jeana Booth, Amanda's Mom

1 episode

Jason Bigio

Officer Brandon Shrout

1 episode

John Laughlin

Detective Troy Pharr

1 episode

Joshua Pivato

Eric

1 episode

David McConnell

Self - True Crime Author

1 episode

Randy Starr

George Weber

1 episode

Georgia Chase

Presenter

1 episode

David Bacque

The Boss

1 episode

Craig Cyr

NY Cop

1 episode

Tina Sterling

Neighbor

1 episode

Jessé Miceli

John Katehis

1 episode

Gino Raimondo

Detective Mark Fleidner

1 episode

Nicole Williams

Jenn Clark (wrongly credited under Jamie Elizabeth Sampson)

1 episode

Nik Rogan

Ray Holycross

1 episode

Samantha Wright Lawrence

Theresa Bridegroom

1 episode

Emily Martell

Mikayla, Jenn's Daughter

1 episode

Allen Corbalan

Connor, Theresa's Son

1 episode

Alan Belerique

Aaron Thomas, Jenn's Friend

1 episode

Ben Mole

Director

1 episode

Ben Mole

Writer

1 episode

Edmund Coulthard

Executive Producer

6 episodes

Harry Hewland

Producer

6 episodes

Ellen Arnold

Executive Producer

6 episodes