Note: The 2015 list on reddit had Rear Window 1959 listed twice at #97 and #185. I used Rear Window 1998 as a place holder at the #185 spot to keep the rest of the rankings accurate. So Rear Window 1998 can be ignored if you are trying to complete this list.
Lists by Year
2016 Edition - https://trakt.tv/users/jaygreene/lists/reddit-top-250-2016-edition?sort=rank,asc
2017 Edition - https://trakt.tv/users/philrivers/lists/reddit-top-250-2017-edition?sort=rank,asc
2018 Edition - https://trakt.tv/users/philrivers/lists/reddit-top-250-2018-edition?sort=rank,asc
2019 Edition - https://trakt.tv/users/jaygreene/lists/reddit-top-250-2019-edition?sort=rank,asc
2019 [No Recency Bias] - https://trakt.tv/users/jaygreene/lists/reddit-top-250-2019-edition-no-recency-bias?sort=rank,asc
Combined List
All Years - https://trakt.tv/users/jaygreene/lists/reddit-top-250-movies-2015-2019?sort=title,asc