All Comments about...

The Killer 2023

Stylish, sleek and punchy; The Killer is as poised and crafted as it's titular protagonist. From the atmospheric, bass forward score to the pace of the streamlined plot, this is just a cool fucking movie that I can't wait to watch again. I'm not as immersed in the Fincher lore as many seem to be here, but I've never come away from one of his movies disappointed yet and The Killer is no exception. Great movie.

loading replies

This is one of the biggest letdowns in years. You simply cannot go wrong with Fassbender, until you go voiceover all the way! The story is never thrilling, clever or original… it’s just a B-movie that was reanimated for a Netflix release. It somehow gave me the same disappointment as George Clooney in The American, but think that movie won by a margin… skip this movie and enjoy the better 2023 releases.

loading replies

Average at best. I mean I’m glad we finally have a Fassbender film, it's been forever, but overall it was kind of a letdown. The first act was good and entertaining, but then things got repetitive and predictable and we ended up watching basically a hitman run errands.

loading replies

No empathy... is his motto... and he kills everyone he encounters, the very innocent vs the guilty yet he spares the rich man's life because he "didn't know what was going on"... Yet he killed the lady and taxi driver when they didn't really know what was going on either? That really knocked off a few points for me because that makes no sense.

loading replies

Film kills me, he gives an epic speech at the start then fucks it up lol he ain't no agent 47

loading replies

A really well script thriller, Fincher knows how to create suspense.

loading replies

What a dumb freaking ending!!!

He says "Empathy is vulnerability, vulnerability is weakness" . So he kills the cab driver , dolores (people who don't deserve to die) but actually leaves the main villain of the story?!! I mean what the f-

I know the villain didn't do it personally, but he still ordered some guy to be killed , that makes him a bad person right?

Seriously, one of the worst David Fincher movies I've ever seen.

Wanna be John Wick.
1/10

loading replies

Felt like the script had been sitting on a shelf for 20 years, but since it's based on a graphic novel that old, that kind of explains it. A C- script elevated to B+ by Fincher's direction and a Reznor/Ross score and excellent sound design.

loading replies

Honestly, would be better without the inner monologuing. I almost lost it during the first 30 minutes.

loading replies

Feels shitty for me to say but this is kinda embarrassing for Fincher. The ending is cool but it's a massively pointless film.

loading replies
6

Shout by jmg999
BlockedParent2023-12-03T17:09:11Z— updated 2024-01-27T02:41:17Z

This was incredibly disappointing. The entire film is described by this expository voiceover in the voice of Michael Fassbender's character. There are only two reasons for such a tool to be used throughout a film: Weak writing or a production company that didn't have the funds to make a film the way in which it was intended. In this case, I think that it was the former. This was a story about nothing that went nowhere, and it had nothing of interest to say along the way. The only reason for the rating I gave it was b/c of the cast. Had they been any less, this film would've ranked a 4/10.

loading replies

Started off really interesting.. the first chapter of the movie gave me a promising premise and I was ready to have a thrilling time, but after the first chapter the plot was getting uninteresting, the side characters were not interesting at all and it was boring as hell. Kinda expected a more thrilling action movie. Fincher did his thing, the dark gritty atmosphere was cool and the very few fighting scenes were well choreographed. By the end of the movie all I was thinking was "should this movie had been made". Its just plain boring and uninteresting. Michael Fassbender was great and Tilda Swinton was also good for the little amount of time she had.

Pros:
Fassbender's acting
Cinematography and the locations
Atmosphere

Cons:
Boring and uninteresting
Underdeveloped and a rushed ending
Uninteresting supporting characters

6/10

loading replies

B-grade trashy genre exploration in an A-grade wrapper. The technical points are nice, and it's neat seeing this genre actively work around current tech, but it lacks a certain narrative substance.

loading replies

It's cool and all but nothing new or special. I'd probably suggest watching The Equalizer instead, or John Wick. Unlike those movies, this one really annoyed me at times.
Definitely not Finchers best.

loading replies

:heart:x6
This felt like a poor man's John Wick. This is just me - but I was bored with this movie. All the way thru it I felt like maybe now it will finally get exciting - but it doesn't. Generally when an action movie has to be narrated from beginning to end - it's going to be bad. And this movie was heavily/primarily narrated. I could go on, but I don't want to spoil anyone else's possible enjoyment of this movie. If I were rating this just for myself - I'd only give it 3 star, but I know some folks will enjoy this type of story-telling.

How I rate:
1-3 :heart: = seriously! don't waste your time
4-6 :heart: = you may or may not enjoy this
7-8 :heart: = I expect you will like this too
9-10 :heart: = movies and TV shows I really love!

loading replies

I get why the mixed reviews and low score for this one. Being a David Fincher movie, I was honestly expecting way more. The pacing is extremely slow, the "assassin" scenes are way to short and not a fan of the narration voiceover. Is distracting, repetitive and doesn't add anything to what it is being shown. The acting from Fassbender wasn't his best. Music is cool, that's why I give it a 5, but it could go lower.

loading replies

A slow, plodding and monotonous revenge movie that even makes Liam Neeson movies look good, the final nail in the coffin being the dull as dishwasher anticlimax ending. The style of the movie with the repetitive “assassin 101” mental notes, presumably to add atmosphere and tension, merely serves to add to the feeling of emptiness that surrounds the whole movie.

loading replies

Throw in a bald-cap and a barcode tattoo—folks, we got ourselves a Hitman reboot. :gun:

loading replies

Started nice but, the rest is awful.

loading replies

Good part is how it starts, his internal monologue is brilliant. I expected too much with that start, ended too low for me. It didn't feel like he took revenge, it was just murder again and again, there was no emotion for us to feel. The person for whom he wants take revenge, we can't relate with that because that person is there for 5 sec. I liked the unforgiving part of him but in the end he messed that too. The surprise kill was also brilliant IMO.

tldr; Meh Movie, You can skip it.

loading replies

A killer kills and tries to kill some more. The end.
Everything else is just filler. It could've been a 5 minute short film.

loading replies

If you turn it off before the ending it's a 7

loading replies

As a devoted David Fincher fan, I was let down by the film's slow pace, lackluster storyline, and predictability.

loading replies

Fassbender does a very good job as the Killer, however his character, as well as the movie, needed a crescendo, a different pace to it. Everything was too slow and in that, the weight of being THE Killer, is lost.

loading replies

Hitman meets John Wick, only slower paced.

That being said it's not unenjoyable, at times it's a little dry or predictable but it held my attention. Fassbender plays his role extremely well, as do all the cast it must be said.

This would be another 6.5 if we could give such a thing, but a 7 works just as well for the acting and 'feel'

loading replies

It's like a long preamble to something huge that never came. It's not a movie but an overproduced high budget monologue. Fassbender was a waste on this one. Directionless and derelict.

loading replies

This definitely looked and felt like a Fincher film, and I think that gives it a lot of leeway with folks, myself included. The life of an assassin is made to feel very unglamorous and just like any other job--there's more work than you'd like to do that goes into every major task. And I was fascinated with the somewhat mundane aspects of such a high stakes profession. Fassbender sells it and covers up some weaker plotting. I know many folks have a problem with the ending feeling inconsistent with the rest of the film, and I'm wishy-washy on it myself, but it did feel like he was making a rational (is it going to cause more trouble if I kill this guy?) decision over an emotional one. Possibly? Anyhow, I still found myself liking this for what it was--a flawed but intriguing film from a master of his craft.

loading replies

I was expecting something to happen the whole movie. It didn't.
Very good acting. Very well sound recordings and operator work. Actually it felt like a game, Max Payne.
But I am overall disappointed. Worst Fincher movie ever.

loading replies

A hitman travels the world seeking revenge for an offense. Rather than being a lackluster film, I found it a tad difficult to digest. Despite mocking itself in many instances, it has a very authorial and contemplative style like MUBI’s newest Czechoslovakian dramatic film. There are interesting moments, but overall, I found it a little bland. It might be worth a second viewing, but honestly, I think I’ll pass.

loading replies

Idk, seems like he did an awful lot of improvising.....

loading replies

I heard David Fincher and I thought I would check it out, but the monotone voice over made it impossible.

loading replies

Such a boring film. David Fincher? Really? it's disappointing.

loading replies

Boring, then boring, at the en boring. 1 fight that is it, a real one, no a skinny girl who eats lettuce knocking a 250 pound dude, nothing more, no action, bad script, I think nowadays directors and actors just take advantage of Netflix, Amazon, 20 years ago, no one read the script and said, ok let's do this, but today the ppl could watch a show about someone inclusive painting a wall and saying , the best movie, the painter break the mold, he Is not a poor latino, he Is the new freedom, jajjaja. Skip it, I would like to see a korean cop movie or an Indian cop drama dance romance instead, at least those movies are something that i could talk during my lunch.

loading replies

there was this one beautiful silhouette shot i really liked, it's around that chapter when he was in florida, then his fight with that man was good, especially the sound design, it was unusually quiet for a fight scene and that exact detail is what drew me in

also his internal monologue throughout the movie was nice, Michael Fassbender was great

loading replies

Wow, that felt really pointless. Somewhere towards the middle I remember thinking "will the whole movie be.. this?" and yes, it was.

loading replies

I couldn't help but keep thinking of "Haywire". Another film with Fassbender playing a killer. Another film by a top-notch director that hit wide of the mark.

This is okay. It passes the time. It keeps your attention and leaves you feeling only mildly short-changed.

I wasn't a big fan of the ending... Illogical given what has transpired. And the internal monologue as narration means that this whole thing has got next to no rewatch value.

Up until the end, I'd have said that Fincher had outdone Soderbergh's efforts in Haywire. But I come out the other side of this now thinking Haywire is superior. It has rewatch value despite its many, many faults.

loading replies

John Wick >>>>>>>>>>>> Fassbender's killer

loading replies

I found it tiring and contradictory.

loading replies

Solid and dense. I didn’t want to be interrupted by anything, which is now a rarity. The cold-blooded, minimalistic style of a simple story about a profession is catchy. One of the people around can be a master in it. Fincher is good! But if you expect some kind of it’s a brand feature, then the movie is certainly not for you.

loading replies

It is a non stop monologue without any great story line, I switched off after an hour as I could not tolerate further.

loading replies

Impressive on the directing and acting side, but hugely disappointing when it comes to writing and story. David Fincher's dependable direction means the film is good at tension building and Michael Fassbender delivers a fantastic performance as a cool and calculating assassin. Unfortunately we're forced to listen to endless monologues from him and this narration quickly got irritating. I was disappointed when the story became a basic vengeance story after the first chapter. The whole thing feels a bit like watching the Hitman video game walkthrough (all these detailed preparation scenes and sneaking around), with some Assassin's Creed-style conversations as the killer chats with his victims. I was drifting off throughout the movie and the ending fell flat completely. The highest point for me was the Florida hand-to-hand fight scene. Just amazing fight choreography and physicality to the whole fight.

loading replies

All the monologue at the beginning and he fails to make the kill makes it look really really embarrassing.

loading replies

Michael Fassbender, always spoke highly of his acting skills and he's always done a great job in his roles and i was impressed once again in this decent film that was sound from start to finish that I enjoyed very much with some good action.

loading replies

Michael wick... yeah good movie finally!!

loading replies

great movie, i enjoyed it a lot. i like well done, slow paced movies and tv series.

loading replies

Slow paced but very nicely executed. Worth a watch. Also Michael Fassbender is amazing as always.

loading replies

A bit too meh for David Fincher. It was stylistic and sleek, but it was all the plating, the food wasn't filling.

loading replies

It's fun. I didn't want to turn it off at any point during it. But there's really no depth to it. What you see is what you get. The story is flat and boring, Michael Fassbender doesn't do anything except for stare with a straight face the entire time. There's no emotion to it. And the ending was just completely unearned.

There's no point in the movie where the killer is interesting. There's no point in the movie where you feel anything for any of the characters involved, except for discomfort for witnessing this stuff. It feels like I'm watching someone else play Hitman 3 without any of the stakes, the intrigue, or the funny parts. It's just bland. Really expected more from David Fincher.

Underwhelming.

loading replies

It was good, Fincher and Fassbender do not disappoint, I always like revenge, but maybe I was expecting something more.

loading replies

Bro how big was that dude? His movement made him look like a CGI monster.

loading replies
9

Shout by jmonty
VIP
2
BlockedParentSpoilers2024-01-02T04:29:39Z

trent and atticus back at it again with the best soundtrack

loading replies

"Vigilance is essential. Even the most disciplined mind can become weary. Impatient. Hurried. Sloppy."

What can I say? It's Fincher! The dude knows how to tell a story and I was not expecting The Killer to be the way it is. I love the attention to detail in the imperfect world. Mistakes happen, followed by precise actions. The colors are classic Fincher as well.

loading replies

13 initials minutes are an monologe destroying any hope in a Society.
Tilda Swinton talk something about pragmatism and cruelty in same situation, depending of one man or other.
Debate: in a link with movie subject, death is an oportunity or a moral sin. Thats the thought of character, I think. But what is cruelty? In death, this and pragmatic action are equal?
To be cruel somebody need a big passionate feelings or calculate steps without it?

loading replies

The type of vibe I wanted from the movie was "relentless". I haven't watched much FIncher yet, but this movie hit all the right spots and Fassbender's always fun to watch.

loading replies

A captivating film, with an intriguing plot, although it can be a little slow at times. It addresses deep reflections on the fragility of human life and the choices that shape our existence.

loading replies

Better than expected and was very entertaining. Even the fight scene was good...most movies over do that part.

9/10

loading replies

I'm sorry. it was so boring, I quit after half the movie

loading replies

The Killer is not for everyone. It portrays a perfectionist and his many imperfections. The story is intelligent. The atmosphere is dark. The filmmaking is exceptional.

loading replies

The first revenge thriller without revenge and thrill. Just a man doing his job and correcting an error in a clean way. Zero emotion. I loved every minute! Finally a movie that I won't forget in a few days. This one was indeed special.

loading replies

I'm a sucker for assassin movies. This one had me glued to the screen for the first act. The story then slowed down quite a bit. I was hoping for a bit more action, a bit more behind the preparation of his moves aside from an endless voice over. A lot of what happened was predictable but not everything.

The Killer is not a perfect assassin and he knows it... and he makes sure that you know it too.

loading replies

Good film and good acting.Fassbender is the great actor.

loading replies

The timing of me learning about sigma and then viewing this film couldn’t have been more perfect. Oh did I see film? More of a filmmaking exercise than an actual film.

loading replies

Entertaining but kind of empty and pointless despite the wannabe-deep voice-over. Easy watch though, just don't expect too much.

loading replies

I found that quite stressful... but, guess that's the point.

loading replies
6

Shout by hhk9
BlockedParent2023-11-23T13:15:02Z— updated 2024-02-18T12:53:23Z

Not the best Fincher movie you'll see

loading replies

It's like Fincher is trying to do Soderbergh and ends up doing Jarmusch. The persistent VO is really something.

loading replies

Don't waste your time the total junk I fell asleep on i

loading replies

the killer kept on saying trust no one all the time and trusted the last guy....

loading replies

Killer Soundtrack, should have used the Smiths and Wesson

loading replies

The ordinary life of a killer.

loading replies

6/10

Not bad, not good. The slow pace of the movie didn’t bother me, i like it. The voice over (his inner voice) was great, but still I expected more. The ending felt rushed. With a better ending this could have been a way better movie. Defiantly a must to watch if you are a fan of fassbender.

loading replies

Very slick and well-shot, great dialogue but a bit of a nothing burger plotwise

loading replies

Very slow paced and uneventful

loading replies

Really reminds me of video games with voices overs

loading replies

It's a love letter to the smiths with a help from Trent Reznor and Portishead as guest star. Without the soundtrack and Fassbenter its a 5-6.

loading replies

I like this genre, but... for someone who reflects a lot on his thoughts, the killer is able to anticipate shit.

loading replies
7

Shout by Frank
BlockedParent2023-11-13T05:05:12Z— updated 2023-12-12T23:44:46Z

I really enjoy this but also kinda disappointed.
It would have been a 8/10 if it wasn’t for that ending.
Michael Fassbender is great and the cinematography.
The supporting cast are sadly underwhelming.
When it comes to the ending he (Michael Fassbender) decides to kill a couple of innocent people without a second thought but then he lets the guy who paid to kill him live for no reason.

loading replies

Almost as if this was Fassbender's audition to play Batman. On another note, it was a ridiculously precise, beautifully shot movie.

loading replies

No substantial plot, and Tilda Swinton is annoying, but it was very well done regardless.

loading replies

This is not a bad movie considering the crap that has come for the past 10 years. A MUST WATCH if there is nothing else to watch.

loading replies

Probably not the movie you will want to watch twice but good enough to get you to the end without boredom.Under par
Fincher ,but good enough thriller or whatever style of movie it was suppose to be.

loading replies
7

Shout by MarkAb
VIP
5
BlockedParentSpoilers2023-11-11T22:19:30Z

Litle bit slow. It’s ok but not an eight.

loading replies

Like the butt of the gun you have in your hand: cold, hard, and oh so solid.

Fassbender makes the role of an elite hitman out for revenge look easy (probably because it is), but what sets this film apart is the tone, which is at once dramatic, sedate and intriguing. David Fincher delivers a film that I couldn't stop watching.

Made with distinctive craft and unique flair, The Killer is my this year's Killers of the Flower Moon.

loading replies

Pretty boring. Had to watch it on 1.5x speed to get through it.

loading replies

I would definitely count David Fincher among the best directors working in Hollywood today. But that doesn't mean that every one of his films is a masterpiece, and I'd also put "The Killer" in the "good, but not great" category. The direction is relatively cold but, at the same time, always stylish. I imagine Fincher approaches his filmmaking in the same way that Michael Fassbender's hitman approaches his missions.

The story is told primarily through Fassbender's voiceovers, a stylistic device that I rarely enjoy. However, it works very well here because it adds a refreshing dose of humor. After all, what the killer says and what actually happens are rarely the same thing. The pace picks up considerably in the second half of the movie. The killer then moves from one location to the next and meets a few colorful characters so that it never gets boring. The resolution is also fitting, making it an entertaining movie experience overall.

loading replies

I liked it but it's a story we have seen many times before, going all the way back to the father of the assassin-for-hire movies, Le Samourai. Ghost Dog was also influenced by it but at least it brought something original by mixing Black culture with Samurai philosophy.

loading replies

I was waiting for this whole year .. Michael Fassbender nailed it .."Stick to the plan.Anticipate, don't improvise. Fight only-the battle you're paid to fight. Trust no one. Forbid empathy. Empathy is a weakness. Weakness is vulnerability. Never yield an advantage. Each and every step of the way, ask yourself, "What's in it for me?". This is what it takes. What you must commit yourself to if you want to succeed. Simple.

loading replies

Excellent. Those w aversion to deliberate pacing and meticulous attention to detail may zone in and out, but I really enjoyed this. Fassbender is superb. Sound design is expectedly top tier. Strong 8.4. Not Fincher's best, and perhaps his most straightforward foray, but the pulpy richness is a treat.

loading replies

I missed these kind of features from Fincher, this kind of acting from Fassbender and this kind of score from this duo. So glad to see it all together. It’s a great but not amazing thriller. I brings the world of the comic book original and adds a lot to it, changes some elements and still waves at who has read the comic (like the scene with the guy on the plane). But for a Fincher thriller it lack being a little bit more punchy and unconventional, and also more intense in the end. Still, enjoyed a lot and specially because I went to the cinema to see this!

loading replies

I haven’t actually seen this but I had a dream last night where I watched it and it was pretty good

loading replies

Hope it won’t rub off John Wick too much, the description seems similar to it.

loading replies
Loading...