Nine young men from across the country compete for the chance to become reality star Brody Jenner's new best friend.
The guys' sense of fun and sportsmanship is put to the test when they compete in a Broathlon comprised of three crazy events: the Downhill Slalom, a Raft Race where the rafts are made entirely of life-sized blow-up dolls, and finally, the Girl's Bike Barrel Jump.
Brody asks each of the guys to plan a group activity that will showcase their personality and creativity. Events vary from mini-golf to stand-up comedy to real tattoos.
The guys decide to head out of town and go camping. But first, they stop off at a biker bar where each of them must test their mettle against a humongous biker in the parking lot. Whoever lasts the longest in the ring without getting thrown out, wins.
There are four remaining guys and they are subjected to a joke by Brody by trying on jeans that they think are of Brody's design. One guy steps up and won't wear the fake denim and is rewarded. One more guy is sent home.
It's the final episode and Brody is pulling out all the stops. This time, Brody enlists the help of his beautiful mother, Linda Thompson, to put each of the guys through a lie detector test to see who's been keeping it real.