(Initial Impression) This show is getting polarized reviews. It seems it is a love it or hate it situation. It is an addition to CW's Arrowverse (Arrow, Flash, Supergirl) and the Ruby Rose's character was introduced to it in a crosssover episode in 2018. It seems to me that it fits into that universe rather well. So, I would suggest that if you follow those show, this might be a good fit for you. But, I can't leave this review without quoting another reviewer, who I think captures the love it/ hate it dilemma rather well, “If you’re not into Batman, Green Arrow, Iron Man , etc, those who are heroes without powers, then this show is not for you. If you’re not into DC heroes, then again, this show isn’t for you. If you’re homophobic or sexist, then you won’t like this show. If you can’t stand good quality shows, then you won’t like this show. Still here? Then you should like this it.” (FangsMcWolf, 7 October 2019 user review on IMDb). I'm not sure I'm ready to brand it a "good quality show" or be as dismissive of it's critics, but I must say I smiled as I read his review. I believe Ruby Rose is getting undeserved criticism for her acting. I think she is embodying a character that IS rather rigid, emotionally fractured and hurt. Overall, I give the series the same rating I give the other Arrowverse series, I give it a 6.5 (OK) out of 10. [Comic Book Heroine]
I was ready to give up on this, but E06 was much better.
Episode 01 wasn’t bad, but it went downhill. Ruby Rose seemed awkward and lacking the acting skills to pull off the part. She’s supported by a good line up of actors, which have been holding the show together.
I suppose it’s a big role to fill and too much for her inexperience. However, E06 she seemed a lot better, more relaxed and comfortable in the role. Let’s hope that continues, as we are getting some great performances from others; such as Alice.
And yes I agree, the previous episodes have been over the top about her sexuality which has been unnecessary and annoying. It’s good to see diversity, but it’s been a tad rammed in our faces. Thankfully E06, this has calmed down too and more focus on the actual show. I’m not really bothered about who is what sexuality, but it’s good to see it being represented. Any show that uses a lot of sexuality annoys me as it’s not necessary to go overboard on it, we aren’t stupid and need things spelling out. That’s not why I watch it; I’m looking for a great show, plot etc.
I still feel this has promise if it continues as well as E06. It’s a lot better than Supergirl; who’s the sickly sweet girl from next door, it’s absolutely annoying! At least Batwoman is more normal in the sense of flaws and not being perfect and soo sweet.
Let’s wait and see how it plays out.
Review by OdinfixBlockedParent2020-05-07T21:54:19Z
While I've liked Ruby Rose in other shows and movies, and I like the Batwoman comics character (this iteration, as well as the B. Gordon version, among others thru the last 20 yrs), this show is just not good. I've liked many of the actors and actresses in other shows as well, but this whole mishmash is just poorly written. Supergirl, the Flash..they're silly and campy (so you can usually overlook when they get preachy)..But the point is ENTERTAINMENT. This..it just isn't. Not to me. I watched the early eps and the Crisis tie-ins..but ever since..Ug!
This character in the comics is a gifted and resourceful person. Period. The fact that it's a woman and gay is part of the story. But there is a Story going on. This..seems to be all Roar and no Substance..and it's all supposed to be okay and embraced Because of the character's gender and sexuality.
It's a lame way to make a movie or a show, no matter how you justify it. Story is All. Or SHOULD be. Political agendas shouldn't be the main focus in a CW show like this. Let's face it, they're brain candy and guilty pleasures for most of us as adults. We want a chance to switch off and enjoy the ride, like watching Marvel movies..Trying to shoehorn these into vehicles for preaching a message...it's like writing Left or Right slogans on a birthday cake, and calling it a serious political discourse. Fun CAN just be about fun, and if it's done well, who really cares about what the character prefers in bed, or their politics, or their gender?