As Holly and Justin work closer together to create a new album, Oscar begins to grow jealous. With his suspicions of Justin mounting, Oscar convinces Holly to let him sit in on all their songwriting sessions to make sure Justin doesn’t try anything. A heart-throb pop star and a jealous boyfriend in the same room? What could go wrong? Although Holly is initially reluctant, she lets Oscar come to a session - and it’s a total failure. Oscar interrupts the creative process, eventually accusing Justin of wanting to steal Holly away from him. Holly feels like this is all her fault until some guidance from Mom makes her realize that Oscar’s trust issues are his problems to fix, not Holly’s.
Dad is disappointed when he discovers Heather’s new secret passion is dance. Heather is hurt by Dad's disapproval of her new hobby, thinking it’s ‘girly’. Mom teaches Dad how he’s bonded with Heather in the past not because she used to play baseball, but because he supported her.
