Blythe stumbles upon some keys belonging to her crush, Josh Sharp, and goes searching for him using Sunil's precognition. When he assumes she has gotten lost due to his own lack of faith in his psychic abilities, he enlists the help of his friends, along with larger-than-life parrot Esteban Banderas.
While on her way to meet with her friends at a flash mob, Blythe gets trapped in the dumbwaiter along with Zoe, Pepper and Minka. While Penny Ling tries to attract the attention of the boys to get them out from the dumbwaiter, Zoe and Pepper start to fight, and within their compact space, Minka's claustrophobia is triggered.
Sunil is mistaken for Shahrukh, a famous movie mongoose hailing from India. The pets bend over backwards to appease him, but quickly lose their patience at his pampered behavior during his stay at the day camp.
Vinnie accidentally falls into a dumpster while trying to catch a fly and is transported to the dump, where he encounters a rat that helps him get back to the pet store. Blythe contracts the common cold and can no longer understand the pets, so the pets try to cure her.
Zoe begs for Blythe to enter her in a reality television series based on a beauty pageant for dogs. What starts off as enjoyable starts to consume Blythe, who becomes driven by winning the pageant, much to the dejection of Zoe.