Mister Rogers brings with him a clay figurine of Randy S. Caribou, and puts him within the Neighborhood of Make-Believe models. Joining the Randy figurine are clay figurines of several other Make-Believe puppet characters. Later in the program, Mister Rogers watches a team of kids playing soccer. When the Make-Believe adventure starts, Randy S. Caribou plays hide-and-seek with the Neighborhood Trolley. But Randy soon puts himself in a sticky situation when he squashes a cake made to look like a soccer ball.
