After leaving prison, Marius takes cover from his past by assuming the identity of his cellmate Pete. He moves in with Pete's long-estranged unsuspecting family and is roped into the family's bail bond business. He's a criminal taking down other criminals and, in the process, discovers the family life he never had.
Marius returns to the farm in hopes of finding a deeper connection with the Bernhardt's but his past soon catches up and tempts him back to the con life. Julia finds herself holding a big secret while serious legal issues put her life and the family business in jeopardy.
Marius falls back in with a dangerous con woman named Lizzie. Fired by Audrey, Julia searches for new employment. Audrey and Otto scramble to save their business. Carly's continued probing about her parents death has emotional ramifications for the Bernhardt family.
Marius must split focus from his con with Lizzie in order to help Julia with a con of her own. Otto enlists Taylor to aid in helping a friend named Lorraine rescue her daughter. Carly uncovers a family secret that leads her out to California and Audrey closer to a painful past she had once left behind.
Marius and Julia travel to Vermont to enlist a reluctant art forger out of retirement. Taylor is suspended from the police force and seeks solace with Lorraine. In California, Audrey must face her estranged father as she agrees to help Carly find the truth about Lila.
Marius and Julia's con takes them out to California. Audrey and Carly follow multiple leads in their search for answers about Lila's whereabouts. Lizzie entangles herself in the Bernhardt family business as a way to keep Marius under her control.
Audrey enlists Marius' help in the search for Lila. They soon discover that her life was far more complicated than they had ever expected. Simmering conflict over Lorraine comes out into the open as Otto and Taylor set out on a cross-country road trip to track down Lizzie.
In the wake of nearly connecting with Lila, the family struggles to come to terms with the idea that she may in fact be alive and in serious danger. Audrey and Otto become unwitting participants in both of Marius' cons.
Julia gets kidnapped and Marius must determine his loyalties as he struggles to keep both cons in motion. The family must figure out a plan to save Julia but they soon realize the situation is more complicated and dangerous than they expected.
Marius must overcome a change in Lizzie's allegiance and maintain the trust of the Bernhardt's. As Taylor and Otto work in earnest to rescue Julia, they find a way to overcome their disagreements. Secrets are revealed, and the family may finally learn the truth about Lila.