Hadi Darbani

Ever since i heard about this movie, I was looking forward to watching it and I'm really glad it lived up to my expectations. A slow and sad story beautifully told from the perspective of the boy. we feel the same emotions as boy feels. some scenes are somehow uncomfortable to watch and I think that shows exactly how well the story telling is done. I also loved the cinematography. Filled with beautiful shots and camerawork. Overall great debut for Paul Dano.

it's only good if you accept there is no logic to this movie at all. there are so many similarities with Shyamalan's "signs" in plot points. but i think signs does a lot better in execution.