Timmy begs Tabitha to not go through with her plan to poison Miguel. Tabitha realizes Charity's powers are growing when she learns Charity is having premonitions of death. In order to keep Miguel and Charity from leaving, Tabitha fakes chest pains and gasps for her pills. She hopes her ""near death"" experience will convince Charity her premonition of death has already come true. Miguel and Charity agree to stay for tea. Charity unwittingly hands the poisoned food to Miguel. Tabitha watches in anticipation as an unsuspecting Miguel takes a bite.
Gwen accuses Ethan of wanting to believe Theresa because he's in love with her. She tells him she doesn't want to see him again until he believes Theresa is lying. Ivy encourages Ethan to seek Theresa's help. Meanwhile, Theresa plans to make Gwen seem like a heartless phony so Ethan will realize she is not the woman for him. Ethan asks Theresa for help with Gwen and Theresa happily agrees. When Theresa tells Ethan to give her Gwen's phone number
