Rodrigo Braz
VIP
7

25 followers

Lisbon, Portugal
33

Silo: 1x01 Freedom Day

Shout by activ
BlockedParentSpoilers2023-05-06T14:28:47Z

I’m confused why the characters seem to think the sherif dying is proof he was wrong. the entire point was that what you see out the camera is not to be trusted.

loading replies

why spoil the second episode by commenting the first one you prick

loading replies
See
7

Reply by Rodrigo Braz
VIP
7
BlockedParent2019-11-03T16:19:55Z— updated 2019-11-05T07:51:13Z

It's okay but there are so many mistakes in the storyline, so much stuff that does not make sense at all that it sometimes hurts to watch. The cinematography is on a really high level - indeed. However, the inconsequence this storyline was written with is disturbing and makes this whole thing a bit of a painful experience. I quite skipped trough it to at least get an overview where this is going.

Maybe they should have done a deep dive how cultures would really develop under these given circumstances. I find it hard to believe that all those people do not know absolutely anything just because there was a virus. And given the fact, that there is no further explanation I bet Apple itself does not have an explanation how this scenario makes any sense.

The only reason I can see why people would give this series a good rating is because of the cinematography, the cast and because it was done by Apple. Because besides those superficial reasons, there is nothing really that justifies a good rating.

loading replies

@vincenzokoestler Sight is not something that is easily explainable to people without it. Given that a large quantity (I don't think they clarify on that) of generations have passed, I could see how globally humanity has forgotten about it. With that other senses would become more developed, which would explain ayuras and the other roles. I guess I don't find it as badly written, or painful, as you do.

loading replies
See

It's okay but there are so many mistakes in the storyline, so much stuff that does not make sense at all that it sometimes hurts to watch. The cinematography is on a really high level - indeed. However, the inconsequence this storyline was written with is disturbing and makes this whole thing a bit of a painful experience. I quite skipped trough it to at least get an overview where this is going.

Maybe they should have done a deep dive how cultures would really develop under these given circumstances. I find it hard to believe that all those people do not know absolutely anything just because there was a virus. And given the fact, that there is no further explanation I bet Apple itself does not have an explanation how this scenario makes any sense.

The only reason I can see why people would give this series a good rating is because of the cinematography, the cast and because it was done by Apple. Because besides those superficial reasons, there is nothing really that justifies a good rating.

loading replies

@vincenzokoestler Please don't drift your arguments into "appropriate" territory. This is fiction, and should be seen as such. This is in no way making a statement about blind people as much as breaking bad is glorifying drugs. Besides, do you think that nothing we achieved is related to sight? The world would be completely upside down. I get that its a giant stretch to fallback into the stone age, but that whats makes it intriguing to me, as a story.

loading replies
Loading...